From tuhs at tuhs.org Sun Nov 1 03:36:12 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (James Frew via TUHS) Date: Sat, 31 Oct 2026 10:36:12 -0700 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> Message-ID: I love the memories this list dredges up: Back in The Day™ I was responsible for a CS student lab full of Teraks, and one of my first tasks was to get a serial line file transfer program running between the Teraks and the dept VAX. The program I inherited was written in PDP-11 assembler, needless to say completely uncommented. So I put my Lions-notes-level reading knowledge of assembler to work and commented it in C so I could understand it. The correspondence was almost 1:1 line-for-line. Pity the Terak didn't have a C compiler... So I'm seconding John's suggestion. Seems like a perfectly do-able task for an LLM! Cheers, /Frew On 2026-10-30 12:49 PM, John Levine via TUHS wrote: > I do not ever recall a PDP-11 to C decompiler. Compiling was painful enough. > On the other hand, the instruction set was small and the translation from C > to machine code was pretty straightforward so it might be interesting to set > an LLM loose on it and see what you get. > > On Fri, Oct 30, 2026 at 11:31 AM John Foust via TUHS wrote: >>> I'm working on a fun project with Prof. Tim Teitelbaum of Cornell, who >>> developed the Cornell Program Synthesizer, an early IDE that ran on the >>> Terak computer. We have an image of an 8" disk with the executables. >>> >>> Source has been lost, so I'd like to try to reconstruct it. He believes >>> the original was in an early C, circa 1979-1982, compiled on >>> (I presume Unix) on maybe an 11/30 and them copied down to the >>> Terak (like a PDP-11/03). >>> >>> Is there an existing tool chain that is good at reconstructing C from >>> binaries of the C compiler of this era? From tuhs at tuhs.org Sun Nov 1 13:30:22 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (John Foust via TUHS) Date: Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:30:22 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> Message-ID: <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> At 12:36 PM 10/31/2026, James Frew via TUHS wrote: >Back in The Day™ I was responsible for a CS student lab full of Teraks, Yes, that was the situation when I was an undergrad at UW-Madison in '81 and that's why I baby-duck imprinted on it and still have ten or so Teraks. >So I'm seconding John's suggestion. Seems like a perfectly do-able task for an LLM! Yes, Claude made short work of it. It studied the V7 'cc' code and its output, it re-used a PDP-11 disassembler toolchain I used for the Terak emulator work I did in another project, and it compared it against Reko's output, and found a few bugs but improved itself, it handled some sections of the binary that were straight assembler instead of C, it read Teitelbaum's paper on his CSP,it analyzed what the code was doing against the Terak hardware, it analyzed the functions and determined what they were doing, it reverse-eningeered the yacc for the PL/CS (PL/I-like) / language based on the decompiled code, and this interatively guided it to name variables and functions, so now I have code like that below. This is 100% Claude's output and creation. LLMs are fun as long as you can throw out everything you thought you knew about the software development process, but also retain all your grey-beard wisdom about what you want and how to get there. - John /* 074544..074722: Unlinks the subtree at the cursor's placeholder: a1 is the address of the subtree's last continuation link. In: a1 link address; curNode, curKind, kindList (list kinds), kindOptional (optional kinds), atListEnd. Out: if that link points back to curNode + 3 (the subtree was the only occupant) curNode's code byte is rewritten as empty: 0105 for a list placeholder, 26 for an optional element, 0116 otherwise; else setLink(curNode, the link's target) so the placeholder skips the removed part, parseLine, and atListHead = 1 (cursor at the list head) unless already at a list end. Calls: getLink, setLink, parseLine. */ unlinkSubtree(a1) int a1; { register int r3, r4; r4 = a1; r3 = getLink(r4); if (r3 == curNode + 3) { if (kindList[curKind] == 0) { if (kindOptional[curKind] == 0) { *(char *)curNode = 0116; } else { *(char *)curNode = 26; } } else { *(char *)curNode = 0105; } } else { setLink(curNode, getLink(r4)); parseLine(); if (atListEnd == 0) { atListHead = 1; } } } From tuhs at tuhs.org Sun Nov 1 23:08:23 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Ralph Corderoy via TUHS) Date: Sun, 01 Nov 2026 13:08:23 +0000 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> Message-ID: <20261101130823.51617C5440@hal.inputplus.co.uk> Hi John, > This is 100% Claude's output and creation. Assuming getLink() doesn't have side effects, line 18's getLink(r4) looks like it can be replaced with r3 given line 6. Is Claude deliberately rendering a duplicate call in the machine code? 1 unlinkSubtree(a1) 2 int a1; 3 { 4 register int r3, r4; 5 r4 = a1; 6 r3 = getLink(r4); 7 if (r3 == curNode + 3) { 8 if (kindList[curKind] == 0) { 9 if (kindOptional[curKind] == 0) { 10 *(char *)curNode = 0116; 11 } else { 12 *(char *)curNode = 26; 13 } 14 } else { 15 *(char *)curNode = 0105; 16 } 17 } else { 18 setLink(curNode, getLink(r4)); 19 parseLine(); 20 if (atListEnd == 0) { 21 atListHead = 1; 22 } 23 } 24 } -- Cheers, Ralph. From tuhs at tuhs.org Mon Nov 2 00:55:17 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Larry McVoy via TUHS) Date: Sun, 1 Nov 2026 06:55:17 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> Message-ID: <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> On Sat, Oct 31, 2026 at 10:30:22PM -0500, John Foust via TUHS wrote: > At 12:36 PM 10/31/2026, James Frew via TUHS wrote: > >Back in The Day? I was responsible for a CS student lab full of Teraks, > > Yes, that was the situation when I was an undergrad at UW-Madison in '81 > and that's why I baby-duck imprinted on it and still have ten or so Teraks. I was there too but not in CS yet. I was undergrad '80-85, grad '86-87. It took me a while to get to CS, I started as an accounting major because my high school coach was also my accounting teacher, so I excelled in high school accounting because, well, coach. College accounting without my coach quickly taught me I hated accounting, still do. I then, much to my culture vulture father's surprise, drifted into Art History. Got good enough in Greek pottery that I pointed out a dating error in Janson. My dad was a physics prof there, he started taking art history classes with me. I became friends with the dean, we'd go out drinking together. He eventually told me "Larry, you are one of the best students I've had, but unless you are willing to do a PhD, there are no jobs, and even then, you'll be in a long line of people for every job". So I went to my dad and said "what do I do?" He gave me some very good advice. He said "It doesn't matter. Well, you can't pick something that goes against your grain like accounting, you have to pick something you like. When you do, learning becomes its own reward". So while I had been drifting around, I had taken a bunch of STEM classes, calc, diffie q, physics (all the easy stuff, I got to quantum mechanics and bowed out, just couldn't wrap my head around probability being the basis). And some CS classes. The data structures course in Pascal resonated with me and I got an A in that. So I picked that. It worked out well for me. All that is to say, John, I don't remember Teraks. I definately remember the terminal room with ~40 terminals hooked up to a VAX 780 (and I fondly remember slovax that had the BSD source on it, I got an account on there eventually and spent a lot of time reading. Ever since then, my main machine has been slovax. slovax is mcvoy.com). So where were the Teraks? I probably got serious in CS around 1982 or 83. Were they still somewhere? --lm From tuhs at tuhs.org Mon Nov 2 01:06:25 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Jeffrey Joshua Rollin via TUHS) Date: Sun, 1 Nov 2026 15:06:25 +0000 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: I have never heard of Teraks. Sounds like an alien species from Star Trek! (I'm of a similar vintage to Dan Cross and am familiar with such things as the separate ports to the 32-bit Interdata machines, although the closest I have gotten to a minicomputer is, depending on your perspective, either using the University library computer terminals which, I later found out, were connected to a VAX of some sort, or occasionally entertaining the idea of buying a PiDP.) Jeff On Sun, 1 Nov 2026, 14:55 Larry McVoy via TUHS, wrote: > On Sat, Oct 31, 2026 at 10:30:22PM -0500, John Foust via TUHS wrote: > > At 12:36 PM 10/31/2026, James Frew via TUHS wrote: > > >Back in The Day? I was responsible for a CS student lab full of Teraks, > > > > Yes, that was the situation when I was an undergrad at UW-Madison in '81 > > and that's why I baby-duck imprinted on it and still have ten or so > Teraks. > > I was there too but not in CS yet. I was undergrad '80-85, grad '86-87. > It took me a while to get to CS, I started as an accounting major because > my high school coach was also my accounting teacher, so I excelled in high > school accounting because, well, coach. College accounting without my > coach quickly taught me I hated accounting, still do. I then, much to my > culture vulture father's surprise, drifted into Art History. Got good > enough in Greek pottery that I pointed out a dating error in Janson. > My dad was a physics prof there, he started taking art history classes > with me. I became friends with the dean, we'd go out drinking together. > He eventually told me "Larry, you are one of the best students I've had, > but unless you are willing to do a PhD, there are no jobs, and even then, > you'll be in a long line of people for every job". > > So I went to my dad and said "what do I do?" He gave me some very good > advice. He said "It doesn't matter. Well, you can't pick something > that goes against your grain like accounting, you have to pick something > you like. When you do, learning becomes its own reward". So while I > had been drifting around, I had taken a bunch of STEM classes, calc, > diffie q, physics (all the easy stuff, I got to quantum mechanics and > bowed out, just couldn't wrap my head around probability being the basis). > And some CS classes. The data structures course in Pascal resonated with > me and I got an A in that. So I picked that. It worked out well for me. > > All that is to say, John, I don't remember Teraks. I definately remember > the terminal room with ~40 terminals hooked up to a VAX 780 (and I > fondly remember slovax that had the BSD source on it, I got an account > on there eventually and spent a lot of time reading. Ever since then, > my main machine has been slovax. slovax is mcvoy.com). > > So where were the Teraks? I probably got serious in CS around > 1982 or 83. Were they still somewhere? > > --lm > From tuhs at tuhs.org Mon Nov 2 01:57:41 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Jon Forrest via TUHS) Date: Sun, 1 Nov 2026 07:57:41 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: <07785eb9-5c57-48cf-9f34-88017e81fc5a@gmail.com> On 11/1/26 7:06 AM, Jeffrey Joshua Rollin via TUHS wrote: > I have never heard of Teraks. They were a version of LSI-11 (similar to a PDP-11/03) that has some special graphics hardware. It had less than 1MB of RAM. I also used the Teraks that Frew mentioned at UCSB to (badly) teach a course in PDP-11 assembler. Each student had their own 8" floppy on which they had a bootable version of RT-11. That version was sufficient to edit, assemble, run, and debug assembler programs. One of the reasons I taught the course so badly was that I had never actually programmed in PDP-11 assembler but I had been around a bunch of assembler programs where I had an internship. One of the professors in CS, Art Pyster, used UCSD Pascal on the Teraks to develop a compiler generator he later described in "Compiler Design and Construction", one of the early books about compilers. Cordially, Jon Forrest From tuhs at tuhs.org Mon Nov 2 02:00:06 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (John Foust via TUHS) Date: Sun, 01 Nov 2026 10:00:06 -0600 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: <7.1.0.9.0.20261101100014.0989e030@threedee.com> At 08:55 AM 11/1/2026, Larry McVoy wrote: >All that is to say, John, I don't remember Teraks. I definately remember >the terminal room with ~40 terminals hooked up to a VAX 780 (and I >fondly remember slovax that had the BSD source on it, I got an account >on there eventually and spent a lot of time reading. Ever since then, >my main machine has been slovax. slovax is mcvoy.com). >So where were the Teraks? I probably got serious in CS around >1982 or 83. Were they still somewhere? The Teraks were used to teach UCSD Pascal to entry-level CS classes and business school programming courses, but they were far more attractive to other CS students because they were $20,000 PDP-11/03 equivalents with mono bitmap graphics and one to four 8" floppies. To be fair, the Teraks were often used as terminals by people sharp enough to have a Terak disk that ran a terminal emulator and connected to their favorite mainframe over the Gandalf serial port switching network. Each Terak had a Gandalf. The Teraks were in their own room in the middle area of the CS basement. You could find them in the math department, too. Yes, there were terminal rooms full of glass TTYs. If the terminal room was full and the Teraks were empty, you could use a Terak as a terminal. There were a few students who were trying to craft their own Unix-alikes for it. You could run RT-11 if you had the disks. There was a more true Unix for the Terak, but I think it was developed in Minnesota and either hadn't made it to Wisconsin when I was there or it was still in development by the time I left. Prof. Teitelbaum's grad student was Tom Reps who went to UW-Madison to teach after the CSP project at Cornell. The CSP is regarded as a milestone on the road to IDEs, as one of the firsts. The CSP was developed using tools from both environments. Its disks are in UCSD p-System format, but the executables appear to have been cross-compiled from a V7 mainframe. But my memories of you are that you were in all those rooms, too. This might jog your memory: https://www.threedee.com/jcm/terak/ Paul Haeberli of SGI was cutting his teeth on Teraks at UW-Madison. Tom Christiansen of Perl was, too. There's a few other UW names in the fine print there. Prof. Bart Miller might've had something to do with the Teraks, as he was under Bowles at UCSD. - John From tuhs at tuhs.org Mon Nov 2 02:05:00 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (John Foust via TUHS) Date: Sun, 01 Nov 2026 10:05:00 -0600 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: <20261101130823.51617C5440@hal.inputplus.co.uk> References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101130823.51617C5440@hal.inputplus.co.uk> Message-ID: <7.1.0.9.0.20261101101010.0989e2c0@threedee.com> At 07:08 AM 11/1/2026, Ralph Corderoy wrote: >Assuming getLink() doesn't have side effects, >line 18's getLink(r4) looks like it can be replaced with r3 given line 6. >Is Claude deliberately rendering a duplicate call in the machine code? I asked, and sent the longer reply in private email. The short answer is "The second getLink call is really in the machine code (two JSRs to getLink at 074556 and 074602 with the same argument, which V7 cc never merged), and the r3 is just the compiler parking the first result during the comparison, which the decompiler rendered as a register variable rather than folding it back into the if." The code appears to be full of horrid "goto", too. - John From tuhs at tuhs.org Mon Nov 2 03:02:33 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Gregg Levine via TUHS) Date: Sun, 1 Nov 2026 12:02:33 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: <07785eb9-5c57-48cf-9f34-88017e81fc5a@gmail.com> References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> <07785eb9-5c57-48cf-9f34-88017e81fc5a@gmail.com> Message-ID: Hello! I remember reading that book. So much so that I found the copy I did read online, and bought it. ---- Gregg C Levine gregg.drwho8 at gmail.com "This signature was once found posting rude messages in English in the Moscow subway." On Sun, Nov 1, 2026 at 10:58 AM Jon Forrest via TUHS wrote: > > > > On 11/1/26 7:06 AM, Jeffrey Joshua Rollin via TUHS wrote: > > I have never heard of Teraks. > They were a version of LSI-11 (similar to a PDP-11/03) > that has some special graphics hardware. It had less than > 1MB of RAM. > > I also used the Teraks that Frew mentioned at UCSB > to (badly) teach a course in PDP-11 assembler. Each > student had their own 8" floppy on which they had > a bootable version of RT-11. That version was sufficient > to edit, assemble, run, and debug assembler programs. > > One of the reasons I taught the course so badly was that > I had never actually programmed in PDP-11 assembler but > I had been around a bunch of assembler programs where > I had an internship. > > One of the professors in CS, Art Pyster, used UCSD Pascal on > the Teraks to develop a compiler generator he later > described in "Compiler Design and Construction", > one of the early books about compilers. > > Cordially, > Jon Forrest > From tuhs at tuhs.org Mon Nov 2 11:13:57 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Clem Cole via TUHS) Date: Sun, 1 Nov 2026 20:13:57 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: The 8510/A was basically an LSI-11 with some graphics hardware, released in 1977. The Terak was arguably the world’s first true standalone graphics workstation. Terak OEM'ed LSI-11 (a KD11-F or maybe the KD11-HA) processor boards from DEC directly, and this used what DEC officially called the 'LSI-11 BUS '; but the world calls it by WD's name, the QBUS. So Terak designed a workstation around DEC's CPU. They built a custom, proprietary chassis, memory system, 8-inch floppy disk controller, and memory-mapped bitmap graphics framebuffer that sat directly in the PDP-11's I/O space. Because they kept the core processor a stock DEC LSI-11 and DEC's I/O layout, the Terak 8510/A can run RT-11, Mini-UNIX, and eventually the UCSD p-System. Theses URL have more details: https://www.threedee.com/jcm/terak/ and Wikipedia: h ttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terak_Corporation https://www.threedee.com/jcm/terak/ The LSI-11 and the Terak system share an interesting, interrelated history. I've forgotten many of the details and sales rules to get the chips and the ROM with the PDP-11-compatible microcode, but WD developed the MCP-1600 chip set and wrote the original microcode (by a real bad-ass programmer named Duane Dickhut, whom I met a few years later). Note that WD and DEC were reasonably tied. Gordon Bell/DEC had created the UART for the PDP-1, and in 1971 a small firm originally called General Digital made and released the first LSI version: the Western Digital WD1402A. Once it was available, it became the standard DEC UART on serial boards, and their business relationship began. As I understand it, in the early 1970s, DEC management had begun to realize it needed some LSI-based computers to protect the low end of its market, but lacked internal silicon fabrication capabilities (DEC Hudson, my future home, was not yet built). So DEC contracted Western Digital in 1974 to co-develop a chipset (DEC paid millions of dollars in NRE charges), planning to use it for a number of systems, starting with the by-then-popular PDP-11 line, but it was getting pressure in the market from other 16-bit players such as DG and HP who were selling at lower price points. At the time, WD was working on the chipset, and DEC had won the lawsuit it filed against California Data Processors (*a.k.a.* CalData). The results of that lawsuit were fresh in the eyes of the team at WD [Ken O'Mohundro and Fred Cox's firm cloned a number of different ISAs but chose the UNIBUS, which got them in trouble. O'Mohundro had famously run the complete 11//40 diagnostics suite for Ken Olson at the National Computer show in CalData's booth]. As for what was normal for the industry, when Western Digital wanted to show off the power of their new chipset, they needed to create a reference design. I've been told some of the senior folks at WD didn't want to piss off DEC, which had been a good business partner for years and >>had<< funded much of the 1600 development. Using another firm's bus seemed unwise, so they created a simpler but 'Unibus-Like' multiplexed 16-bit address/data bus layout. DEC's engineers later took the original WD bus design, "refined" (I like to say peed on it to make it more DEC-like), and formally branded it the LSI-11 Bus. Roll the clock forward, and Terak comes around. So they built their devices for the CPU they had picked and created an early workstation. I'm not 100% sure if Ken Bowles and the UCSD team had a real DEC LSI-11 like the 11/03 as the first target, but at some point they discovered the Tek 8510/A, which, as I understand it, became the 'master system'/gold standard for the UCSD Pascal system. Their trick was to take the P4 Pascal reference compiler from Wirth and his students in Europe, reimplement its bytecode interpreter for a target ISA, expand it a bit, and wrap a development system around it. At some point they targeted their interpreter to the LSI-11 processor, Terak's I/O system, and in particular, its framebuffer. Since Pascal had by then become the standard teaching language in many universities, many of them purchased the 8510/A (which I suspect is how many people learned about them). You could also get the original p-System for free from UCSD on 8 floppies or on a distribution tape, and it would run on something like an LSI-11 with a VT-52 or VT-100 instead of the Terak if you configured it appropriately; I suspect many universities did that as well. In an interesting twist of fate, in 1979, because of the academic success of the UCSD p-System running on top of their own silicon (via DEC's LSI-11 p-code interpreter), Western Digital's engineers and management saw an opportunity, thinking: *“Why use an interpreter to translate p-code into PDP-11 code? Let's just burn the p-code interpreter directly into the microcode.” *The result was the WD/9000. I know it had new microcode, but I think they also updated and replaced the control-chip portion of their chipset family. Of course, by late 1979, Motorola had released the 68000 and the age of UNIX workstations had begun, and I think the Western Digital Pascal System was doomed and the 16-bit nature of the PDP-11 killed the Terak. On Sun, Nov 1, 2026 at 10:06 AM Jeffrey Joshua Rollin via TUHS < tuhs at tuhs.org> wrote: > I have never heard of Teraks. > > Sounds like an alien species from Star Trek! > > (I'm of a similar vintage to Dan Cross and am familiar with such things as > the separate ports to the 32-bit Interdata machines, although the closest I > have gotten to a minicomputer is, depending on your perspective, either > using the University library computer terminals which, I later found out, > were connected to a VAX of some sort, or occasionally entertaining the idea > of buying a PiDP.) > > Jeff > > On Sun, 1 Nov 2026, 14:55 Larry McVoy via TUHS, wrote: > > > On Sat, Oct 31, 2026 at 10:30:22PM -0500, John Foust via TUHS wrote: > > > At 12:36 PM 10/31/2026, James Frew via TUHS wrote: > > > >Back in The Day? I was responsible for a CS student lab full of > Teraks, > > > > > > Yes, that was the situation when I was an undergrad at UW-Madison in > '81 > > > and that's why I baby-duck imprinted on it and still have ten or so > > Teraks. > > > > I was there too but not in CS yet. I was undergrad '80-85, grad '86-87. > > It took me a while to get to CS, I started as an accounting major because > > my high school coach was also my accounting teacher, so I excelled in > high > > school accounting because, well, coach. College accounting without my > > coach quickly taught me I hated accounting, still do. I then, much to my > > culture vulture father's surprise, drifted into Art History. Got good > > enough in Greek pottery that I pointed out a dating error in Janson. > > My dad was a physics prof there, he started taking art history classes > > with me. I became friends with the dean, we'd go out drinking together. > > He eventually told me "Larry, you are one of the best students I've had, > > but unless you are willing to do a PhD, there are no jobs, and even then, > > you'll be in a long line of people for every job". > > > > So I went to my dad and said "what do I do?" He gave me some very good > > advice. He said "It doesn't matter. Well, you can't pick something > > that goes against your grain like accounting, you have to pick something > > you like. When you do, learning becomes its own reward". So while I > > had been drifting around, I had taken a bunch of STEM classes, calc, > > diffie q, physics (all the easy stuff, I got to quantum mechanics and > > bowed out, just couldn't wrap my head around probability being the > basis). > > And some CS classes. The data structures course in Pascal resonated with > > me and I got an A in that. So I picked that. It worked out well for me. > > > > All that is to say, John, I don't remember Teraks. I definately remember > > the terminal room with ~40 terminals hooked up to a VAX 780 (and I > > fondly remember slovax that had the BSD source on it, I got an account > > on there eventually and spent a lot of time reading. Ever since then, > > my main machine has been slovax. slovax is mcvoy.com). > > > > So where were the Teraks? I probably got serious in CS around > > 1982 or 83. Were they still somewhere? > > > > --lm > > > From tuhs at tuhs.org Mon Nov 2 11:34:24 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Bakul Shah via TUHS) Date: Sun, 1 Nov 2026 17:34:24 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: <6F0E0FEF-7F61-4A30-8BA9-DEF2CB4229CA@iitbombay.org> On Nov 1, 2026, at 5:13 PM, Clem Cole via TUHS wrote: > > The 8510/A was basically an LSI-11 with some graphics hardware, released in > 1977. The Terak was arguably the world’s first true standalone graphics > workstation. In 1976 or so I wrote some code to play with graphics. It was to simulate a fly-through a wire-frame dodecahedron to be displayed on a GT40 (this one also had the lunar lander program). I do not recall now if my code was cross-compiled on a TOPS-10 system or compiled right on the GT40 but it certainly seemed like a standalone graphics computer.... From tuhs at tuhs.org Mon Nov 2 12:10:03 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Jon Forrest via TUHS) Date: Sun, 1 Nov 2026 18:10:03 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: On 11/1/26 5:13 PM, Clem Cole via TUHS wrote: > At the time, WD was working on the chipset, and DEC had won the lawsuit it > filed against California Data Processors (*a.k.a.* CalData). The results of > that lawsuit were fresh in the eyes of the team at WD [Ken O'Mohundro and > Fred Cox's firm cloned a number of different ISAs but chose the UNIBUS, > which got them in trouble. O'Mohundro had famously run the complete 11//40 > diagnostics suite for Ken Olson at the National Computer show in CalData's > booth]. Ken O'Mohundro - there's a name I haven't heard in a while. In the early 1980s I ran the Santa Barbara VMS Users Group. At the time, there were a few vendors who were starting to make DEC-compatible peripherals, such as memory, and disk/communication/network controllers. One of the vendors was Able, in Orange County, CA. Somehow Ken contacted me to ask if he could come talk to our users group about DEC stuff. Ken was a self-described stutterer who enjoyed addressing groups of people as a form of speech therapy. So, he came all the way up to Santa Barbara from Irvine and gave a nice presentation. IIRC, Able Computer paid for lunch for everyone. He was a very nice guy. Cordially, Jon Forrest From tuhs at tuhs.org Mon Nov 2 12:16:55 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Clem Cole via TUHS) Date: Sun, 1 Nov 2026 21:16:55 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: <6F0E0FEF-7F61-4A30-8BA9-DEF2CB4229CA@iitbombay.org> References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> <6F0E0FEF-7F61-4A30-8BA9-DEF2CB4229CA@iitbombay.org> Message-ID: Fair. Did it have a disk of any type and was the local OS? Was it really standalone? I didn't think there was room in the case for anything else. I believe DEC created the GT44 which I believe could but I never saw one in the wild. FWIW. I also had a GT40 with an 11/05 CPU with a Unibus, but no local storage or an OS like DOS-11 or RT11. My experience was it had a 960 cps serial connection to its mothership, our Unix system in my case or to an ASR33 with its papertape reader. In our case we had a runtime we used for the Graphics code which I wrote part of as part Bob Sproull's graphics course. It was similar to the ones for 3-Rivers GPD which had dedicated 11/20 and a connection to CS-Front End so they usually used one of the PDP-10s, C.mmp or one of the Unix systems as a mothership. In my case I used the Unix V6 C compiler, as and led. I wrote a loader for what GT40 ROM wanted, although I've completely forgotten and of those details. Also I know that when when Jack wrote Moonlander, he was using a PDP-10 for his development and downloaded to the GT40. I think he was using PPT. He told me once how he did the development, but I dont remember that detail, although I think he was using macro-11x and must have had some sort of load system. All editing, however, was done on the PDP-10. The Terack was sold as a complete 'PC' if will. Not needing anything else to support it. Sent from a handheld expect more typos than usual On Sun, Nov 1, 2026 at 8:34 PM Bakul Shah wrote: > On Nov 1, 2026, at 5:13 PM, Clem Cole via TUHS wrote: > > > > The 8510/A was basically an LSI-11 with some graphics hardware, released > in > > 1977. The Terak was arguably the world’s first true standalone graphics > > workstation. > > In 1976 or so I wrote some code to play with graphics. It was to simulate > a fly-through a wire-frame dodecahedron to be displayed on a GT40 (this > one also had the lunar lander program). I do not recall now if my code > was cross-compiled on a TOPS-10 system or compiled right on the GT40 but > it certainly seemed like a standalone graphics computer.... From tuhs at tuhs.org Mon Nov 2 13:15:04 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Clem Cole via TUHS) Date: Sun, 1 Nov 2026 22:15:04 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: Indeed. Great guy. The Unix community stop solidly on his shoulders for many years. I haven't spoken to him in years. After the CalData lawsuit and when he created Able, he said he'd only make peripherals and swore off CPUs. His DMAX (DH/DM) became pretty much required if you were part of USENET, particularly if you had Telebit Modems. He made a lots money selling them to the Unix community. He knew it was very appreciative. He used to come to USENIX conferences regularly and warn us to watch out about Unibus implementations from a number of the 3rd party vendors. Which with him being one himself, was humorous. Besides his famous replacements for DEC's terminal mux products, he also made bus repeaters and caches. At an early USENIX shortly after he had released a cache for the 11/34, a couple of us were at dinner and I was sitting next to him. In those days, besides being a Unix hacker, I was also designing hardware and had just designed the MMU for the Tek Magnolia. So I asked Ken, since he was moving the Unibus memory down stream of his cache, why couldn't put a new MMU in it, and basically NOP the DEC MMU, but split 22-bit adresses out the other end. We sketched something and he said he would think about it. About a month or two later he calls me and asked if I wanted to try what he just finished. They ended up calling it the "Enable" and allowed 11/40 and 11/45 class systems to address up to 4M like the 11/70. If you google it, you'll find Noel's page on Gunkies. Noel also has links to the paper I wrote about it, as well as scan of the prepublication user manual and a sketch of the registers it supported whicj I had sent Noel a few years ago. The code is actually still 2.11BSD but disabled since it's no longer relevant as 2.11 pretty much requires an 11/70 and boards are hard to find these days. BTW, a few years later Mike O'Dell and I tried to get him to make a version on the DMAX for the ISA or EISA bus. We also suggested making an Ethernet version with a 68000 in it and we would wrote the code for it, since putting serial ports, particularly ones with modems, on PC hardware was such a losing proposition. But Ken told us that margins for PC peripherals was too low for him make any money on it. Soon there after we all bought Livingston boxes to do the job. I always felt bad, as I think would have done a great job if could have figured it out. BTW: he did eventually break his rule about CPUs slightly. He ended up creating a QBUS 68010 CPU board that he showed me when I visited him in Irvine at some point. I don't know how well it sold and lost track of him after that as I left the Vax/PDP-11 world and when I returned to it to work on Alpha, I never ran into him. Sent from a handheld expect more typos than usual On Sun, Nov 1, 2026 at 9:11 PM Jon Forrest via TUHS wrote: > > > On 11/1/26 5:13 PM, Clem Cole via TUHS wrote: > > > At the time, WD was working on the chipset, and DEC had won the lawsuit > it > > filed against California Data Processors (*a.k.a.* CalData). The results > of > > that lawsuit were fresh in the eyes of the team at WD [Ken O'Mohundro > and > > Fred Cox's firm cloned a number of different ISAs but chose the UNIBUS, > > which got them in trouble. O'Mohundro had famously run the complete > 11//40 > > diagnostics suite for Ken Olson at the National Computer show in > CalData's > > booth]. > Ken O'Mohundro - there's a name I haven't heard in a while. In the early > 1980s I ran the Santa Barbara VMS Users Group. At the time, there were a > few vendors who were starting to make DEC-compatible peripherals, such > as memory, and disk/communication/network controllers. One of the > vendors was Able, in Orange County, CA. Somehow Ken contacted me to > ask if he could come talk to our users group about DEC stuff. Ken > was a self-described stutterer who enjoyed addressing groups of > people as a form of speech therapy. So, he came all the way up > to Santa Barbara from Irvine and gave a nice presentation. IIRC, > Able Computer paid for lunch for everyone. > > He was a very nice guy. > > Cordially, > Jon Forrest > > From tuhs at tuhs.org Mon Nov 2 16:49:06 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Marc Donner via TUHS) Date: Mon, 2 Nov 2026 01:49:06 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: UNIBUS - that’s a term I haven’t heard in tears. At JPL as a young EE right out of college I designed a UNIBUS monitor that my boss used in various installations. That educated me about the bus, so years later I recognized that the Motorola 68000 had essentially implemented it faithfully, with the exception of making the Sync signal active-low instead of active-high (a true blessing in TTL days). ===== [My messages are from me, not from AI.] exploringaimatters.com nygeek.net On Sun, Nov 1, 2026 at 10:16 PM Clem Cole via TUHS wrote: > Indeed. Great guy. The Unix community stop solidly on his shoulders for > many years. I haven't spoken to him in years. After the CalData lawsuit > and when he created Able, he said he'd only make peripherals and swore off > CPUs. His DMAX (DH/DM) became pretty much required if you were part of > USENET, particularly if you had Telebit Modems. He made a lots money > selling them to the Unix community. He knew it was very appreciative. He > used to come to USENIX conferences regularly and warn us to watch out about > Unibus implementations from a number of the 3rd party vendors. Which with > him being one himself, was humorous. > > Besides his famous replacements for DEC's terminal mux products, he also > made bus repeaters and caches. At an early USENIX shortly after he had > released a cache for the 11/34, a couple of us were at dinner and I was > sitting next to him. In those days, besides being a Unix hacker, I was > also designing hardware and had just designed the MMU for the Tek > Magnolia. So I asked Ken, since he was moving the Unibus memory down > stream of his cache, why couldn't put a new MMU in it, and basically NOP > the DEC MMU, but split 22-bit adresses out the other end. We sketched > something and he said he would think about it. > > About a month or two later he calls me and asked if I wanted to try what he > just finished. They ended up calling it the "Enable" and allowed 11/40 and > 11/45 class systems to address up to 4M like the 11/70. If you google it, > you'll find Noel's page on Gunkies. Noel also has links to the paper I > wrote about it, as well as scan of the prepublication user manual and a > sketch of the registers it supported whicj I had sent Noel a few years > ago. The code is actually still 2.11BSD but disabled since it's no longer > relevant as 2.11 pretty much requires an 11/70 and boards are hard to find > these days. > > BTW, a few years later Mike O'Dell and I tried to get him to make a version > on the DMAX for the ISA or EISA bus. We also suggested making an Ethernet > version with a 68000 in it and we would wrote the code for it, since > putting serial ports, particularly ones with modems, on PC hardware was > such a losing proposition. But Ken told us that margins for PC peripherals > was too low for him make any money on it. > > Soon there after we all bought Livingston boxes to do the job. I always > felt bad, as I think would have done a great job if could have figured it > out. > > BTW: he did eventually break his rule about CPUs slightly. He ended up > creating a QBUS 68010 CPU board that he showed me when I visited him in > Irvine at some point. I don't know how well it sold and lost track of him > after that as I left the Vax/PDP-11 world and when I returned to it to work > on Alpha, I never ran into him. > > > Sent from a handheld expect more typos than usual > > On Sun, Nov 1, 2026 at 9:11 PM Jon Forrest via TUHS wrote: > > > > > > > On 11/1/26 5:13 PM, Clem Cole via TUHS wrote: > > > > > At the time, WD was working on the chipset, and DEC had won the lawsuit > > it > > > filed against California Data Processors (*a.k.a.* CalData). The > results > > of > > > that lawsuit were fresh in the eyes of the team at WD [Ken O'Mohundro > > and > > > Fred Cox's firm cloned a number of different ISAs but chose the UNIBUS, > > > which got them in trouble. O'Mohundro had famously run the complete > > 11//40 > > > diagnostics suite for Ken Olson at the National Computer show in > > CalData's > > > booth]. > > Ken O'Mohundro - there's a name I haven't heard in a while. In the early > > 1980s I ran the Santa Barbara VMS Users Group. At the time, there were a > > few vendors who were starting to make DEC-compatible peripherals, such > > as memory, and disk/communication/network controllers. One of the > > vendors was Able, in Orange County, CA. Somehow Ken contacted me to > > ask if he could come talk to our users group about DEC stuff. Ken > > was a self-described stutterer who enjoyed addressing groups of > > people as a form of speech therapy. So, he came all the way up > > to Santa Barbara from Irvine and gave a nice presentation. IIRC, > > Able Computer paid for lunch for everyone. > > > > He was a very nice guy. > > > > Cordially, > > Jon Forrest > > > > > From tuhs at tuhs.org Tue Nov 3 01:06:08 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (al kossow via TUHS) Date: Mon, 2 Nov 2026 07:06:08 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> <6F0E0FEF-7F61-4A30-8BA9-DEF2CB4229CA@iitbombay.org> Message-ID: <784565bd-8734-4eae-aaea-eab2f9751acc@bitsavers.org> On 11/1/26 6:16 PM, Clem Cole via TUHS wrote: > I believe DEC created the GT44 which I believe could but I never saw one in > the wild. > GT44 was an 11/40 with RK05s and the VT11 display processor GT46 swapped the 11/40 for an 11/34. We had one at UW-Milwaukee I think it was the first computer there to run V7 Unix From tuhs at tuhs.org Tue Nov 3 02:00:49 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Clem Cole via TUHS) Date: Mon, 2 Nov 2026 11:00:49 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: On Mon, Nov 2, 2026 at 1:49 AM Marc Donner wrote: > That educated me about the bus, so years later I recognized that the > Motorola 68000 had essentially implemented it faithfully, with the > exception of making the Sync signal active-low instead of active-high (a > true blessing in TTL days). > Yup, it is very close and was intended to be, as it was a model, but the designers were careful not to make it exactly like it. Remember, what became the 68000 was a skunkworks project and >>not<< an 'official' project at Moto. Les Crudele, Nick Tradenick, and a couple of others had joined Moto from Schlumberger, where they had been interfacing PDP-11 control systems for the oil drilling industry and were extremely familiar with both the PDP-11 ISA and the Unibus. But Les says he and the team were very careful. The bet they had with Tom Grunner was that they could basically build a PDP-11 on a single chip using Motorola's current process technology. Tom was interested enough to let them try in the back of the lab. But those folks (particularly Tom, as I understand it) were all extremely aware of the CalData lawsuit. Thus, they made sure the ISA and bus were 'different enough'. For instance, Nick made the instruction set use the same addressing modes and functions, but isn't the same, using address and data registers instead of general registers. I've long forgotten the specifics of the differences, but similarly Les said he spent a lot of time thinking about what we could use from the Unibus and QBUS, but still be different enough that they would not be taken to court as CalData had. The fact that, a few years later, Ken O'Mohundro put a 68010 on a QBUS fairly easily is living proof it wasn't that far off. The rest of the story of how 68000 went from being a skunkworks project to a real product is cool, and I am honored to have helped play a small part in that story with the TekLabs's Magnolia system; but it's not relevant here. From tuhs at tuhs.org Tue Nov 3 02:19:41 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Clem Cole via TUHS) Date: Mon, 2 Nov 2026 11:19:41 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: <784565bd-8734-4eae-aaea-eab2f9751acc@bitsavers.org> References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> <6F0E0FEF-7F61-4A30-8BA9-DEF2CB4229CA@iitbombay.org> <784565bd-8734-4eae-aaea-eab2f9751acc@bitsavers.org> Message-ID: below On Mon, Nov 2, 2026 at 10:06 AM al kossow via TUHS wrote: > > On 11/1/26 6:16 PM, Clem Cole via TUHS wrote: > > I believe DEC created the GT44 which I believe could but I never saw one > in > > the wild. > > > GT44 was an 11/40 with RK05s and the VT11 display processor > Running RT-11, I would suspect - do you know? > > GT46 swapped the 11/40 for an 11/34. We had one at UW-Milwaukee > Do you remember when they were released? > > I think it was the first computer there to run V7 Unix > Cool, so that was in 1979 or later, since that's when V7 was released. Do you remember how much memory it had? BTW: Neither V6 nor V7 had a VT-11 driver, nor did the DEC V7M tape. If memory serves me, there might have been one of the earlier USENIX tapes, or did you folks write one yourself? Clem From tuhs at tuhs.org Tue Nov 3 03:53:29 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Lawrence Stewart via TUHS) Date: Mon, 2 Nov 2026 12:53:29 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: <5FE4F696-6EA4-4410-8625-ABE899D42A9D@serissa.com> > On Nov 2, 2026, at 11:00, Clem Cole via TUHS wrote: > > On Mon, Nov 2, 2026 at 1:49 AM Marc Donner wrote: > >> That educated me about the bus, so years later I recognized that the >> Motorola 68000 had essentially implemented it faithfully, with the >> exception of making the Sync signal active-low instead of active-high (a >> true blessing in TTL days). >> > Yup, it is very close and was intended to be, as it was a model, but the > designers were careful not to make it exactly like it. Remember, what > became the 68000 was a skunkworks project and >>not<< an 'official' project > at Moto. Les Crudele, Nick Tradenick, and a couple of others had joined > Moto from Schlumberger, where they had been interfacing PDP-11 control > systems for the oil drilling industry and were extremely familiar with both > the PDP-11 ISA and the Unibus. But Les says he and the team were very > careful. The bet they had with Tom Grunner was that they could basically > build a PDP-11 on a single chip using Motorola's current process > technology. Tom was interested enough to let them try in the back of the > lab. But those folks (particularly Tom, as I understand it) were all > extremely aware of the CalData lawsuit. Thus, they made sure the ISA and > bus were 'different enough'. For instance, Nick made the instruction set > use the same addressing modes and functions, but isn't the same, using > address and data registers instead of general registers. I've long > forgotten the specifics of the differences, but similarly Les said he spent > a lot of time thinking about what we could use from the Unibus and QBUS, > but still be different enough that they would not be taken to court as > CalData had. The fact that, a few years later, Ken O'Mohundro put a 68010 > on a QBUS fairly easily is living proof it wasn't that far off. > > The rest of the story of how 68000 went from being a skunkworks project to > a real product is cool, and I am honored to have helped play a small part > in that story with the TekLabs's Magnolia system; but it's not relevant > here. It is not well known, but the first DEC Systems Research Center “Firefly” multiprocessor was actually a 68010. It drove a QBUS for I/O. We never went into production because we were able to get 78032 Microvax II chips in time. This would have been late 1984 or early 1985 IIRC. Chuck Thacker did the hardware design for the 68010 version, and I wrote the boot roms. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DEC_Firefly Not exactly TUHS, but the connection is the Firefly OS would run standard Ultrix-32 binaries. From tuhs at tuhs.org Wed Nov 4 09:02:07 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Mary Ann Horton via TUHS) Date: Tue, 3 Nov 2026 15:02:07 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: <7.1.0.9.0.20261101100014.0989e030@threedee.com> References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261101100014.0989e030@threedee.com> Message-ID: This is bringing back so many wonderful memories. I was at UW-Madison from 76 to 78 but we just had an 11/45 running V6 and an array of dumb terminals. In 19777, that was my intro to UNIX and I was soooo hooked. My main contribution was the hed editor - an enhanced ed. I was very loyal to it until Bill Joy gave me vi. After I transferred to Berkeley in 78, my PhD dissertation was what I called a "language editor". The Reps/Teitelbaum CPS system was one of my inspirations. I didn't realize they had it running on a Terak - I'd never heard of it until now. And I didn't know UW-Madison was using Terak workstations around 1980. Even when I went to Bell Labs, I didn't get a GUI until 88 when I got a BLIT. (IBM PCs didn't count.) CPS and many similar systems had you edit program parse trees rather than editing text. Instead of inserting and deleting text, you'd graft and prune trees. It was a creative idea, but I felt it was too restrictive on the user. Syntax errors were impossible, comments were part of the syntax and could only go in certain places. My approach was that you'd edit the tree, but with a textual user interface, so I built a mechanism for arbitrary text attached to a node in the tree. My tool, Babel, would perform incremental parsing and semantic error checking and highlight errors as soon as the text operation completed. (Eclipse and MS Visual Studio followed, but I wasn't involved.) Babel ran on Ernie (a VAX 11/780) and was horribly slow. A typical insertion took about 1 minute. It worked but wasn't a useful tool. Was CPS used by students on the Terak? How was the experience? I'm curious how CPS performance was on the Terak. Processors are just a bit faster now...  A few years ago I briefly brought up 3BSD on simh and ran the Babel binary. It was speedy, but I'd used the BREAK key to begin commands, and that doesn't translate today. One of these days I'll port it to modern C and play with it. Thanks, /Mary Ann Horton/ (she/her/ma'am)       Keynote Speaker on Inclusion and Innovation       Award Winning Author maryannhorton.com On 11/1/26 08:00, John Foust via TUHS wrote: > At 08:55 AM 11/1/2026, Larry McVoy wrote: >> All that is to say, John, I don't remember Teraks. I definately remember >> the terminal room with ~40 terminals hooked up to a VAX 780 (and I >> fondly remember slovax that had the BSD source on it, I got an account >> on there eventually and spent a lot of time reading. Ever since then, >> my main machine has been slovax. slovax is mcvoy.com). >> So where were the Teraks? I probably got serious in CS around >> 1982 or 83. Were they still somewhere? > The Teraks were used to teach UCSD Pascal to entry-level CS classes > and business school programming courses, but they were far more > attractive to other CS students because they were $20,000 > PDP-11/03 equivalents with mono bitmap graphics and one to > four 8" floppies. > > To be fair, the Teraks were often used as terminals by people > sharp enough to have a Terak disk that ran a terminal emulator > and connected to their favorite mainframe over the Gandalf > serial port switching network. Each Terak had a Gandalf. > > The Teraks were in their own room in the middle area of > the CS basement. You could find them in the math department, too. > Yes, there were terminal rooms full of glass TTYs. > If the terminal room was full and the Teraks were empty, > you could use a Terak as a terminal. > > There were a few students who were trying to craft their own > Unix-alikes for it. You could run RT-11 if you had the disks. > There was a more true Unix for the Terak, but I think it was > developed in Minnesota and either hadn't made it to Wisconsin > when I was there or it was still in development by the time I left. > > Prof. Teitelbaum's grad student was Tom Reps who went to UW-Madison > to teach after the CSP project at Cornell. The CSP is regarded as > a milestone on the road to IDEs, as one of the firsts. > > The CSP was developed using tools from both environments. Its > disks are in UCSD p-System format, but the executables appear > to have been cross-compiled from a V7 mainframe. > > But my memories of you are that you were in all those rooms, too. > > This might jog your memory: > > https://www.threedee.com/jcm/terak/ > > Paul Haeberli of SGI was cutting his teeth on Teraks at UW-Madison. > Tom Christiansen of Perl was, too. There's a few other UW names > in the fine print there. Prof. Bart Miller might've had something > to do with the Teraks, as he was under Bowles at UCSD. > > - John From tuhs at tuhs.org Wed Nov 4 09:41:52 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (John Foust via TUHS) Date: Tue, 03 Nov 2026 17:41:52 -0600 Subject: [TUHS] Terak Mini-UNIX In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> <6F0E0FEF-7F61-4A30-8BA9-DEF2CB4229CA@iitbombay.org> Message-ID: <7.1.0.9.0.20261103174156.080c7838@threedee.com> Claude and I analyzed the Terak-Unix at Bitsavers https://bitsavers.trailing-edge.com/bits/Terak/mini-unix/. The Terak Unix on Bitsavers is based on Heinz Lycklama's MINI-UNIX (Bell Labs, 1977: UNIX Sixth Edition for PDP-11s without memory management), ported to the Terak 8510/a's QX floppy controller. Aado Perandi, a graduate student at the University of Minnesota, built the first Terak UNIX in spring 1979. It was described in the University Computing Center's newsletter in May 1979. The work was done on a PDP-11/40 running Unix V6 and copied to ten Terak 8" floppies, IBM 3740 SSSD. The C is V6, the libraries using the newer archive format from PWB V7. Perandi's modifications were lost in a disk failure that summer and he left; Marc G. Smith at SICL (the Special Interactive Computations Laboratory within the Space Science Center), redeveloped it from "mostly from scratch" and was still distributing floppies in April 1980. A troublesome flaw is that the swap area is kept on the boot floppy but the Terak hardware did not have any disk-changed notification. If you removed the boot floppy from the boot drive and inserted another and then the system swapped, it would write over whatever was on the second floppy. Many of the disks images on Bitsavers show this. Claude decompiled the binaries and restored them as C source, compared against the MINI-UNIX source, determined the changes that Smith made and the other Terak-unique parts, compiled it all again within my Terak emulator, rebuilding the kernel in a minute, and confirmed everything matches to the byte. I will pass my repairs to Bitsavers as soon as I figure out how to do that. Perandi and Smith are still around, I reached out but haven't had a response. >From my own perspective, I'm puzzled as to why this UNIX didn't make it to UW-Madison's Teraks as far as I remember. The interest was certainly there; I remember an elite hacker who crafted a Unix-alike under the UCSD p-System, with a shell that ran p-System executables with short names. Perhaps it was the cost of ten floppies and student programmers were broke back then. - John From tuhs at tuhs.org Wed Nov 4 10:12:34 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (ROBERT MYERS via TUHS) Date: Tue, 3 Nov 2026 18:12:34 -0600 Subject: [TUHS] Are various DEC UNIXes targeted to address space and/or Floating Point implemented? References: <759F09CA-499A-49E1-8078-8E11B3D72D4A.ref@yahoo.com> Message-ID: <759F09CA-499A-49E1-8078-8E11B3D72D4A@yahoo.com> I have a 11/83 with floating point and a 11/23+ that I haven’t determined if it does. Both have 22 bits of address space. Both will have either a QBone or QBone Duo module. Any issues with running Various Unixes on them? I know the 11/83 has 4Mb of PMI memory and the 11/23+ will have emulated memory of up to 4Mb. Sent from my iPhone From tuhs at tuhs.org Wed Nov 4 10:23:02 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (segaloco via TUHS) Date: Wed, 04 Nov 2026 00:23:02 +0000 Subject: [TUHS] Are various DEC UNIXes targeted to address space and/or Floating Point implemented? In-Reply-To: <759F09CA-499A-49E1-8078-8E11B3D72D4A@yahoo.com> References: <759F09CA-499A-49E1-8078-8E11B3D72D4A.ref@yahoo.com> <759F09CA-499A-49E1-8078-8E11B3D72D4A@yahoo.com> Message-ID: On Tuesday, November 3rd, 2026 at 16:12, ROBERT MYERS via TUHS wrote: > > I have a 11/83 with floating point and a 11/23+ that I haven’t determined if it does. Both have 22 bits of address space. Both will have either a QBone or QBone Duo module. > > Any issues with running Various Unixes on them? I know the 11/83 has 4Mb of PMI memory and the 11/23+ will have emulated memory of up to 4Mb. > > Sent from my iPhone > There is a paper describing UNIX on the 11/23 here: https://www.tuhs.org/Archive/Documentation/TechReports/USG_Library/1588_UNIX_on_the_PDP11_23_and_PDP11_34_Computers.pdf That may be relevant to what you're trying to do. - Matt G. From tuhs at tuhs.org Wed Nov 4 10:54:57 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Larry McVoy via TUHS) Date: Tue, 3 Nov 2026 16:54:57 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] Are various DEC UNIXes targeted to address space and/or Floating Point implemented? In-Reply-To: <759F09CA-499A-49E1-8078-8E11B3D72D4A@yahoo.com> References: <759F09CA-499A-49E1-8078-8E11B3D72D4A.ref@yahoo.com> <759F09CA-499A-49E1-8078-8E11B3D72D4A@yahoo.com> Message-ID: <20261104005457.GJ24641@mcvoy.com> On Tue, Nov 03, 2026 at 06:12:34PM -0600, ROBERT MYERS via TUHS wrote: > > I have a 11/83 with floating point and a 11/23+ that I haven???t determined if it does. Both have 22 bits of address space. Both will have either a QBone or QBone Duo module. > > Any issues with running Various Unixes on them? I know the 11/83 has 4Mb of PMI memory and the 11/23+ will have emulated memory of up to 4Mb. Other than "just because it is cool", wouldn't running whatever on a simulator work just as well and run faster? Don't get me wrong, I learned assembler on a PDP-ll, Kendall Witte is who I'm pretty sure was my TA, the instruction set was so well thought out, he could come over, crack open a beer, look at the octal dump of what I was running and read it like it was the assembler. Made a big impression on me, that's a very clean instruction set. This crowd probably all knows, but the PDP-11 instruction set sort of did everything in a way that you could read it in an octal dump, there were patterns and the patterns didn't vary. I also loved the PDP-11 because it gave me a mental model of what a computer is that I use to this day. Yeah, computers today are way more complex, but the basic model still holds true. Can any of you imagine showing someone x86 and saying "see, that's a computer" and expect anyone to have a mental model they can reason about? I liked the National 320xx series as well, it seemed like it was trying to be a modern PDP-11 but they never worked the bugs out and it went nowhere. The 680xx seemed like it was actually a modern PDP-11 but I didn't get the sense the instruction set was as clean as the PDP-11, Clem or anyone care to comment? From tuhs at tuhs.org Wed Nov 4 11:15:24 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (ROBERT MYERS via TUHS) Date: Tue, 3 Nov 2026 19:15:24 -0600 Subject: [TUHS] Are various DEC UNIXes targeted to address space and/or Floating Point implemented? In-Reply-To: <20261104005457.GJ24641@mcvoy.com> References: <20261104005457.GJ24641@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: My problem with this is that the build scripts for windows and visual studio haven’t been brought up to date for Windows 11 and Visual Studio 2026. I also have to come up to speed with GitHub, cmake, and any other requirements to build under this environment. Since I have the 11/83 and 11/23+ machines, there is I believe Unix v6 targeting a 11/73 emulation (going from memory; had to remove a hard drive & controller as my 11/83 is in a questionable state right now). Sent from my iPhone On Nov 3, 2026, at 6:55 PM, Larry McVoy wrote: On Tue, Nov 03, 2026 at 06:12:34PM -0600, ROBERT MYERS via TUHS wrote: > > I have a 11/83 with floating point and a 11/23+ that I haven???t determined if it does. Both have 22 bits of address space. Both will have either a QBone or QBone Duo module. > > Any issues with running Various Unixes on them? I know the 11/83 has 4Mb of PMI memory and the 11/23+ will have emulated memory of up to 4Mb. Other than "just because it is cool", wouldn't running whatever on a simulator work just as well and run faster? Don't get me wrong, I learned assembler on a PDP-ll, Kendall Witte is who I'm pretty sure was my TA, the instruction set was so well thought out, he could come over, crack open a beer, look at the octal dump of what I was running and read it like it was the assembler. Made a big impression on me, that's a very clean instruction set. This crowd probably all knows, but the PDP-11 instruction set sort of did everything in a way that you could read it in an octal dump, there were patterns and the patterns didn't vary. I also loved the PDP-11 because it gave me a mental model of what a computer is that I use to this day. Yeah, computers today are way more complex, but the basic model still holds true. Can any of you imagine showing someone x86 and saying "see, that's a computer" and expect anyone to have a mental model they can reason about? I liked the National 320xx series as well, it seemed like it was trying to be a modern PDP-11 but they never worked the bugs out and it went nowhere. The 680xx seemed like it was actually a modern PDP-11 but I didn't get the sense the instruction set was as clean as the PDP-11, Clem or anyone care to comment? From tuhs at tuhs.org Wed Nov 4 12:23:40 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Larry McVoy via TUHS) Date: Tue, 3 Nov 2026 18:23:40 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] Are various DEC UNIXes targeted to address space and/or Floating Point implemented? In-Reply-To: References: <20261104005457.GJ24641@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: <20261104022340.GL24641@mcvoy.com> Well then go for it. I wouldn't mind being in front of an actual PDP-11 all these years later. I'm 64, my PDP-11 days are 40 years ago but I remember those days very fondly. It was a great machine, big enough and small enough. I fish on the ocean on a boat that is described the same way, I have a big small boat or small big boat. It's good enough in much the same way the PDP-11 was good enough, you could run a multi user Unix on a 64KB (and banks and I think you got to 256KB?), I fish on the ocean in my boat, got a 157 pound bluefin this year (been chasing that for 3 years, finally got one). It's a small but capable boat, pretty much like the PDP-11. The fact that Unix worked, multi user, on such a small machine is amazing. Huge credit to Dennis and Ken and team making things small, that is a lost art, my browser, one tab, has 37GB virtual, 5GB real. That's one tab. Don't get me started about slack, it's just as bad. We are a long way from PDP-11 unix, you want to go run that, go you. On Tue, Nov 03, 2026 at 07:15:24PM -0600, ROBERT MYERS wrote: > My problem with this is that the build scripts for windows and visual studio haven???t been brought up to date for Windows 11 and Visual Studio 2026. I also have to come up to speed with GitHub, cmake, and any other requirements to build under this environment. > > Since I have the 11/83 and 11/23+ machines, there is I believe Unix v6 targeting a 11/73 emulation (going from memory; had to remove a hard drive & controller as my 11/83 is in a questionable state right now). > > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Nov 3, 2026, at 6:55???PM, Larry McVoy wrote: > > ???On Tue, Nov 03, 2026 at 06:12:34PM -0600, ROBERT MYERS via TUHS wrote: > > > > I have a 11/83 with floating point and a 11/23+ that I haven???t determined if it does. Both have 22 bits of address space. Both will have either a QBone or QBone Duo module. > > > > Any issues with running Various Unixes on them? I know the 11/83 has 4Mb of PMI memory and the 11/23+ will have emulated memory of up to 4Mb. > > Other than "just because it is cool", wouldn't running whatever on a > simulator work just as well and run faster? > > Don't get me wrong, I learned assembler on a PDP-ll, Kendall Witte is who > I'm pretty sure was my TA, the instruction set was so well thought out, > he could come over, crack open a beer, look at the octal dump of what I > was running and read it like it was the assembler. Made a big impression > on me, that's a very clean instruction set. This crowd probably all > knows, but the PDP-11 instruction set sort of did everything in a way > that you could read it in an octal dump, there were patterns and the > patterns didn't vary. > > I also loved the PDP-11 because it gave me a mental model of what a > computer is that I use to this day. Yeah, computers today are way more > complex, but the basic model still holds true. Can any of you imagine > showing someone x86 and saying "see, that's a computer" and expect anyone > to have a mental model they can reason about? > > I liked the National 320xx series as well, it seemed like it was trying to > be a modern PDP-11 but they never worked the bugs out and it went nowhere. > The 680xx seemed like it was actually a modern PDP-11 but I didn't get > the sense the instruction set was as clean as the PDP-11, Clem or anyone > care to comment? -- --- Larry McVoy Retired to fishing http://www.mcvoy.com/lm/boat From tuhs at tuhs.org Wed Nov 4 13:06:56 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (ROBERT MYERS via TUHS) Date: Tue, 3 Nov 2026 21:06:56 -0600 Subject: [TUHS] Are various DEC UNIXes targeted to address space and/or Floating Point implemented? In-Reply-To: <20261104022340.GL24641@mcvoy.com> References: <20261104005457.GJ24641@mcvoy.com> <20261104022340.GL24641@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: <17BEAF0F-5BDF-402F-905B-4FD42DCE160B@yahoo.com> I’m actually 69 and I went to C_MU with Clem a number of years back. I’m trying to understand more about emulation of hardware and software but have run into a few stumbling blocks with Open-Simh (PDP-11 portion). I’m hoping to get the PDP-11 code running by the end of the year, since I fear maintenance of the repository has not been kept up to date with current OS and development software distributions. From tuhs at tuhs.org Wed Nov 4 13:07:55 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Clem Cole via TUHS) Date: Tue, 3 Nov 2026 22:07:55 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] Are various DEC UNIXes targeted to address space and/or Floating Point implemented? In-Reply-To: <759F09CA-499A-49E1-8078-8E11B3D72D4A@yahoo.com> References: <759F09CA-499A-49E1-8078-8E11B3D72D4A.ref@yahoo.com> <759F09CA-499A-49E1-8078-8E11B3D72D4A@yahoo.com> Message-ID: 2.11BSD will boot fine. https://minnie.tuhs.org/PUPS/Setup/2.11bsd_setup.html has an older version of Steven's steup guide. https://www.tuhs.org/cgi-bin/utree.pl?file=2.11BSD/doc/2.10/setup.2.11 has the troff for a version from a few years later; but I'm pretty sure you an find a pdf of it also. On Tue, Nov 3, 2026 at 7:12 PM ROBERT MYERS via TUHS wrote: > > I have a 11/83 with floating point and a 11/23+ that I haven’t determined > if it does. Both have 22 bits of address space. Both will have either a > QBone or QBone Duo module. > > Any issues with running Various Unixes on them? I know the 11/83 has 4Mb > of PMI memory and the 11/23+ will have emulated memory of up to 4Mb. > > Sent from my iPhone > From tuhs at tuhs.org Wed Nov 4 13:23:27 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Clem Cole via TUHS) Date: Tue, 3 Nov 2026 22:23:27 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] Are various DEC UNIXes targeted to address space and/or Floating Point implemented? In-Reply-To: <20261104005457.GJ24641@mcvoy.com> References: <759F09CA-499A-49E1-8078-8E11B3D72D4A.ref@yahoo.com> <759F09CA-499A-49E1-8078-8E11B3D72D4A@yahoo.com> <20261104005457.GJ24641@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: On Tue, Nov 3, 2026 at 7:55 PM Larry McVoy via TUHS wrote > > I liked the National 320xx series as well, it seemed like it was trying to > be a modern PDP-11 but they never worked the bugs out and it went nowhere. > Actually, the model was the VAX; but you are right. I never understood why they never quite get it together, and they lost their window to the 68020/68030 > The 680xx seemed like it was actually a modern PDP-11 but I didn't get > the sense the instruction set was as clean as the PDP-11, Clem or anyone > care to comment? > I discussed this a few days ago in the [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries thread, replying to Marc's comment about the 68000's bus being close to the Unibus. Given the goals, I think it was very clean. It used all the same addressing modes. Even the instruction-word bit layout is extremely recognizable from the PDP-11. The real difference was that it had address and data registers instead of general registers, which I suspect is the source of your gripe. But blame DEC for suing Ken O'Mohundro and Fred Cox @ CalData for making a true PDP-11 clone for the choice Nick and Les made with the 68000 ISA. copy/pasted from that message: On Mon, Nov 2, 2026 at 1:49 AM Marc Donner wrote: > That educated me about the bus, so years later I recognized that the > Motorola 68000 had essentially implemented it faithfully, with the > exception of making the Sync signal active-low instead of active-high (a > true blessing in TTL days). > Yup, it is very close and was intended to be, as it was a model, but the designers were careful not to make it exactly like it. Remember, what became the 68000 was a skunkworks project and >>not<< an 'official' project at Moto. Les Crudele, Nick Tradenick, and a couple of others had joined Moto from Schlumberger, where they had been interfacing PDP-11 control systems for the oil drilling industry and were extremely familiar with both the PDP-11 ISA and the Unibus. But Les says he and the team were very careful. The bet they had with Tom Grunner was that they could basically build a PDP-11 on a single chip using Motorola's current process technology. Tom was interested enough to let them try in the back of the lab. But those folks (particularly Tom, as I understand it) were all extremely aware of the CalData lawsuit. Thus, they made sure the ISA and bus were 'different enough'. For instance, Nick made the instruction set use the same addressing modes and functions, but isn't the same, using address and data registers instead of general registers. I've long forgotten the specifics of the differences, but similarly Les said he spent a lot of time thinking about what we could use from the Unibus and QBUS, but still be different enough that they would not be taken to court as CalData had. The fact that, a few years later, Ken O'Mohundro put a 68010 on a QBUS fairly easily is living proof it wasn't that far off. The rest of the story of how 68000 went from being a skunkworks project to a real product is cool, and I am honored to have helped play a small part in that story with the TekLabs's Magnolia system; but it's not relevant here. From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 5 04:49:01 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Arnold Robbins via TUHS) Date: Wed, 04 Nov 2026 11:49:01 -0700 Subject: [TUHS] What does `ld` stand for? Message-ID: <202611041849.6A4In13I045763@freefriends.org> Hi All. Douglas McIlroy via TUHS wrote: > Fortran came with source code. I stayed up with that one night > debugging a bizarre error: failure on computed gotos with 74 mod 75 > branches. I wouldn't be surprised if our unlucky customer was the only > user ever to stumble on that one. I asked for more stories like this. Here's Doug's reply (by permission). Followups should probably go to COFF. > There's actually more to the Fortran-bug story. The bug involved a > programming trick as bizarre as the symptom. > > The instruction set for the IBM 700 series had an index-register "tag" > field.. A loop instruction (TIX) counted an index down to zero, with a > conditional transfer on non-zero. A store-tag instruction was > introduced in the 709. I never saw an STT in use--except for > this bug. > > A loop that counted blocks of 75 computed-goto > addresses for spilling to secondary storage was controlled by > TIX, but in an extraordinary way. The fall-through was controlled > by zeroing out the tag rather than by reaching zero. Since the > condition was sensed elsewhere, it had to be detected on > every path that led to the TIX, and the programmer had missed > one. > > What, I wonder, inspired the creation of this baroque scheme? From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 5 06:20:23 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Lyndon Nerenberg (VE7TFX/VE6BBM) via TUHS) Date: Wed, 04 Nov 2026 13:20:23 -0700 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: <9f28c38cf2d4fa5c@orthanc.ca> > The fact that, a few years later, Ken O'Mohundro put a 68010 > on a QBUS fairly easily is living proof it wasn't that far off. Was this the precursor to the NBI 68010 QBUS Unix system (I forget the marketing model name or number). I owned on of those at home back in the day[1], complete with 10 Mb/s ethernet board and a DH-11. It ran an off-the-tape compilation of 4.2 BSD, and it was absolutely covinced it was a VAX :-) I was running a small usenet hub on it, and when I connected the Telebit, the machine started to panic in the DH11 driver under 9600+ baud serial load when there was also any ethernet traffic present. I called a friend and said "please send me dh11.c and .h from the 4.2 release tape." Compiling them required changing a single #define (compile for QBUS, not UNIBUS). I re-linked the kernel, rebooted, and the problem vanished! Oh how I miss that machine. It was like I had a VAX in the 2nd bedroom, but with a proper CPU :-) --lyndon [1] I first ran into one circa 1987 at a lawyer's office. I acquired mine in 1991. From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 5 12:22:31 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (segaloco via TUHS) Date: Thu, 05 Nov 2026 02:22:31 +0000 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: <9f28c38cf2d4fa5c@orthanc.ca> References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> <9f28c38cf2d4fa5c@orthanc.ca> Message-ID: On Wednesday, November 4th, 2026 at 12:20, Lyndon Nerenberg (VE7TFX/VE6BBM) via TUHS wrote: > > The fact that, a few years later, Ken O'Mohundro put a 68010 > > on a QBUS fairly easily is living proof it wasn't that far off. > > Was this the precursor to the NBI 68010 QBUS Unix system (I forget > the marketing model name or number). > > I owned on of those at home back in the day[1], complete with > 10 Mb/s ethernet board and a DH-11. It ran an off-the-tape > compilation of 4.2 BSD, and it was absolutely covinced it was > a VAX :-) > > I was running a small usenet hub on it, and when I connected the > Telebit, the machine started to panic in the DH11 driver under 9600+ > baud serial load when there was also any ethernet traffic present. > I called a friend and said "please send me dh11.c and .h from the > 4.2 release tape." Compiling them required changing a single #define > (compile for QBUS, not UNIBUS). I re-linked the kernel, rebooted, > and the problem vanished! > > Oh how I miss that machine. It was like I had a VAX in the 2nd > bedroom, but with a proper CPU :-) > > --lyndon > > [1] I first ran into one circa 1987 at a lawyer's office. I > acquired mine in 1991. > All this UNIBUS/QBUS talk has me wondering, what with the clear influence of the PDP-11 on the M68000, was there also a line connecting VERSAbus and later VMEbus back to the DEC tradition of system buses? For the record, some of the early non-DEC System V targets are M68K systems based on VERSA and VME bus systems. VME then goes onto feature in numerous other UNIX targets, among them the WE321SB single board and Sun machines. - Matt G. From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 5 12:49:50 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Clem Cole via TUHS) Date: Wed, 4 Nov 2026 21:49:50 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> <9f28c38cf2d4fa5c@orthanc.ca> Message-ID: On Wed, Nov 4, 2026 at 9:22 PM segaloco via TUHS wrote: > > All this UNIBUS/QBUS talk has me wondering, what with the clear > influence of the PDP-11 on the M68000, was there also a line connecting > VERSAbus and later VMEbus back to the DEC tradition of system buses? > As best I can tell, only indirectly. VERSAbus and VMEbus competed with Intel's Multibus and Multibus-II. When Intel originally created Multibus, they were trying to address the issues with the S-100 bus. DEC's PDP-8 Ominibus and Unibus had been around for a long time by then. I don't think the LSI-11/QBUS was yet official. Multibus certainly looked more like the DEC bus offerings than the S-100 bus, and like DEC when they started, Intel tried to lock them up the same way DEC had done. By Multibus-II, they certainly succeeded. But Multibus, like the S-100 bus and the later PC buses, ended up being 'open.' For example, the Stanford University Network 68000 board was Multibus-based, and I don't believe any of their licensees such as VLSI Systems (ney Sun Micro) needed a license of any type from Intel. The Apollo and Masscomp systems also used Multibus as their I/O bus. But I know that in the latter case, Masscomp made some extensions on the undefined connector part of the board edge. All of their CPUs worked with COTS Multibus I/O boards, but when Dave Cain created the memory system for the MC-500, he was fresh off leading both the Comet (750) and the BI projects at DEC, and Masscomp's memory bus looked more like the BI than anything else. FWIW: IIRC, Moto tried to lock up the VMEbus a bit, and I don't know how well that worked out. ISTR that Sun switched to it at some point, but somewhat abandoned it in their own design by the time of the SPARC, although the larger systems that need more demanding controllers like the ones Xylogic's built, I think stayed using VME as the I/O bus for a good bit. Someone like Larry is likely to know much more about that. Clem From tuhs at tuhs.org Fri Nov 6 01:04:45 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (al kossow via TUHS) Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2026 07:04:45 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> <9f28c38cf2d4fa5c@orthanc.ca> Message-ID: <461c1fea-5e03-496b-8b2f-66376b31cb46@bitsavers.org> No, that was Integrated Solutions, with people who came from Zilog (the reason all their peripheral controllers used Z8000s) http://bitsavers.org/pdf/isi Cadmus also sold a Qbus 68K system On 11/4/26 6:22 PM, segaloco via TUHS wrote: >>> The fact that, a few years later, Ken O'Mohundro put a 68010 >>> on a QBUS fairly easily is living proof it wasn't that far off. >> Was this the precursor to the NBI 68010 QBUS Unix system (I forget >> the marketing model name or number). >> From tuhs at tuhs.org Sat Nov 7 08:04:16 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (segaloco via TUHS) Date: Fri, 06 Nov 2026 22:04:16 +0000 Subject: [TUHS] Some new USG PG3 Scans Message-ID: The weather is changing and I've also used up my CI/CD minutes on GitLab in a matter of days, so something is telling me November is a month for scanning instead. As such, I've started chipping away at some of the USG documentation I've acquired in the past year. Here's a bit of what I've started on: https://archive.org/details/unix-program-documents-program-generic-issue-3 After the link is an archive.org listing which I'll be slowly adding documents to. For now, it contains PG-1C300 Issue 3, which is the documentation index for USG Program Generic Issue 3, as well as PO-1C300-01, the System Initialization section including descriptions of bootstrapping and installing the system. This listing will be a bit of a slow burn as I work through the various papers involved, but basically amounts to "Volume 2" or "Documents for UNIX" for the Program Generic releases. For the record, a number of these documents are also captured as part of the USG Library archive on TUHS. I believe the copies in the USG Library archive to be closer to the Program Generic Issue 2 era whereas these are from Issue 3. For instance, the installation instructions have been updated. Anywho, I'll reply here as more of this is scanned. Be forewarned that these are not first-generation copies, so are a bit fuzzy already. Still, when completed, this should result in nearly all of the PG 3 documentation being preserved. There are a few odds and ends missing, some of which are filled in by the USG Library, but I'll do a more thorough breakdown once all the documents are scanned. I also plan to mirror these over to the TUHS archive but am going to get it all scanned up to archive.org first. - Matt G. From tuhs at tuhs.org Sat Nov 7 11:45:35 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Sevan Janiyan via TUHS) Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2026 01:45:35 +0000 Subject: [TUHS] Link rot on the wiki Message-ID: <0d984533-55fb-400f-9011-32fee471bb11@geeklan.co.uk> Hi, ukuug.org domain is now squatted, https://wiki.tuhs.org/doku.php?id=publications:magazines needs updating to point the like for the The UK Unix Users Group archive of newsletters to point to https://web.archive.org/web/20120205123700/http://www.ukuug.org/newsletter/ and couple of spelling mistakes in https://www.tuhs.org/Archive/Documentation/Unix_Review/Readme --- Readme.txt.orig 2026-11-07 01:40:23.000000000 +0000 +++ Readme.txt 2026-11-07 01:41:06.000000000 +0000 @@ -1,4 +1,4 @@ -This is a palce to stope scanned copies of the Unix Review magazine. +This is a place to store scanned copies of the Unix Review magazine. The file http://simson.net/ref/free_software/Berkeley_Unix_History.pdf contains scans of articles from Unix Review about the history of Unix Sincerely, Sevan From tuhs at tuhs.org Sat Nov 7 12:33:04 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (segaloco via TUHS) Date: Sat, 07 Nov 2026 02:33:04 +0000 Subject: [TUHS] Intuity and Audix From Lucent? Message-ID: I've just archived a set of five Lucent Technologies 1.44MB floppy disks labeled INTUITY R4 and subtitled AUDIX R4.3/R4.4, with labels indicating UnixWare boot and emergency diskettes along with a Pentium HBA driver. https://archive.org/details/unixware-for-intuity-r4 I don't really know anything about this other than it's late UNIX stuff from Lucent, so piqued my interest when I saw the disks for sale. The dumps are simple dd rips of the floppy disks. I haven't done any analysis of the images yet, just wanted to get them dumped and uploaded. If anyone knows more about this stuff, I'd certainly appreciate a second set of eyes. In any case when I've got a bit more time (on the way out the door) I plan on digging around the data contained within. A cursory glance reveals readable strings throughout so I suspect the dumps are good. - Matt G. From tuhs at tuhs.org Tue Nov 10 03:15:36 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Kevin Bowling via TUHS) Date: Mon, 9 Nov 2026 10:15:36 -0700 Subject: [TUHS] Intuity and Audix From Lucent? In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: On Fri, Nov 6, 2026 at 7:34 PM segaloco via TUHS wrote: > > I've just archived a set of five Lucent Technologies 1.44MB floppy disks > labeled INTUITY R4 and subtitled AUDIX R4.3/R4.4, with labels indicating > UnixWare boot and emergency diskettes along with a Pentium HBA driver. > > https://archive.org/details/unixware-for-intuity-r4 > > I don't really know anything about this other than it's late UNIX stuff > from Lucent, so piqued my interest when I saw the disks for sale. The > dumps are simple dd rips of the floppy disks. >From what I have seen these were voicemail appliances that connected to a PBX. They used standard PC hardware on a large PICMG backplane with many ISA slots for TDM boards that interfaced the voice calls to the voicemail software. A fairly common 1990s computer telephony setup. There is a decent chance these are standard UnixWare boot disks, in that case, you can go get the full media kit already on archive.org and elsewhere. > I haven't done any analysis of the images yet, just wanted to get them > dumped and uploaded. If anyone knows more about this stuff, I'd > certainly appreciate a second set of eyes. In any case when I've got a > bit more time (on the way out the door) I plan on digging around the > data contained within. A cursory glance reveals readable strings > throughout so I suspect the dumps are good. > > - Matt G. From tuhs at tuhs.org Tue Nov 10 05:31:33 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Cody Logan via TUHS) Date: Mon, 09 Nov 2026 19:31:33 +0000 Subject: [TUHS] Intuity and Audix From Lucent? In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: <0HfcQFINUvTN5DWy4qw6zFMCZRPITxO4SQWLqltTz-ObGoArBIUKN29w0Z_BPl8t65Rk27G-QVjlcy3u1zAETz-_b_td7069TyOClPfYM4k=@pm.me> Related, there's a set of QIC tapes containing Intuity/Audix software up for sale on eBay right now: https://www.ebay.com/itm/235936619065 On Monday, November 9th, 2026 at 9:16 AM, Kevin Bowling via TUHS wrote: > On Fri, Nov 6, 2026 at 7:34 PM segaloco via TUHS wrote: > > > > I've just archived a set of five Lucent Technologies 1.44MB floppy disks > > labeled INTUITY R4 and subtitled AUDIX R4.3/R4.4, with labels indicating > > UnixWare boot and emergency diskettes along with a Pentium HBA driver. > > > > https://archive.org/details/unixware-for-intuity-r4 > > > > I don't really know anything about this other than it's late UNIX stuff > > from Lucent, so piqued my interest when I saw the disks for sale. The > > dumps are simple dd rips of the floppy disks. > > From what I have seen these were voicemail appliances that connected > to a PBX. They used standard PC hardware on a large PICMG backplane > with many ISA slots for TDM boards that interfaced the voice calls to > the voicemail software. A fairly common 1990s computer telephony > setup. > > There is a decent chance these are standard UnixWare boot disks, in > that case, you can go get the full media kit already on archive.org > and elsewhere. > > > I haven't done any analysis of the images yet, just wanted to get them > > dumped and uploaded. If anyone knows more about this stuff, I'd > > certainly appreciate a second set of eyes. In any case when I've got a > > bit more time (on the way out the door) I plan on digging around the > > data contained within. A cursory glance reveals readable strings > > throughout so I suspect the dumps are good. > > > > - Matt G. > -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: signature.asc Type: application/pgp-signature Size: 603 bytes Desc: OpenPGP digital signature URL: From tuhs at tuhs.org Tue Nov 10 05:58:01 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Madeline Autumn-Rose via TUHS) Date: Mon, 9 Nov 2026 11:58:01 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] Intuity and Audix From Lucent? In-Reply-To: <0HfcQFINUvTN5DWy4qw6zFMCZRPITxO4SQWLqltTz-ObGoArBIUKN29w0Z_BPl8t65Rk27G-QVjlcy3u1zAETz-_b_td7069TyOClPfYM4k=@pm.me> References: <0HfcQFINUvTN5DWy4qw6zFMCZRPITxO4SQWLqltTz-ObGoArBIUKN29w0Z_BPl8t65Rk27G-QVjlcy3u1zAETz-_b_td7069TyOClPfYM4k=@pm.me> Message-ID: <4115226B-2FD5-4C69-B3D0-9A3401DFC684@gewt.net> I need several of these for some actual telecoms systems, anyone mind if pick these up? Imaging planned or would loan them for imaging. Sent from my iPhone > On Nov 9, 2026, at 11:31, Cody Logan via TUHS wrote: > > Related, there's a set of QIC tapes containing Intuity/Audix software up for sale on eBay right now: https://www.ebay.com/itm/235936619065 > >> On Monday, November 9th, 2026 at 9:16 AM, Kevin Bowling via TUHS wrote: >> >>> On Fri, Nov 6, 2026 at 7:34 PM segaloco via TUHS wrote: >>> >>> I've just archived a set of five Lucent Technologies 1.44MB floppy disks >>> labeled INTUITY R4 and subtitled AUDIX R4.3/R4.4, with labels indicating >>> UnixWare boot and emergency diskettes along with a Pentium HBA driver. >>> >>> https://archive.org/details/unixware-for-intuity-r4 >>> >>> I don't really know anything about this other than it's late UNIX stuff >>> from Lucent, so piqued my interest when I saw the disks for sale. The >>> dumps are simple dd rips of the floppy disks. >> >> From what I have seen these were voicemail appliances that connected >> to a PBX. They used standard PC hardware on a large PICMG backplane >> with many ISA slots for TDM boards that interfaced the voice calls to >> the voicemail software. A fairly common 1990s computer telephony >> setup. >> >> There is a decent chance these are standard UnixWare boot disks, in >> that case, you can go get the full media kit already on archive.org >> and elsewhere. >> >>> I haven't done any analysis of the images yet, just wanted to get them >>> dumped and uploaded. If anyone knows more about this stuff, I'd >>> certainly appreciate a second set of eyes. In any case when I've got a >>> bit more time (on the way out the door) I plan on digging around the >>> data contained within. A cursory glance reveals readable strings >>> throughout so I suspect the dumps are good. >>> >>> - Matt G. > From tuhs at tuhs.org Tue Nov 10 06:15:29 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (al kossow via TUHS) Date: Mon, 9 Nov 2026 12:15:29 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] Intuity and Audix From Lucent? In-Reply-To: <4115226B-2FD5-4C69-B3D0-9A3401DFC684@gewt.net> References: <0HfcQFINUvTN5DWy4qw6zFMCZRPITxO4SQWLqltTz-ObGoArBIUKN29w0Z_BPl8t65Rk27G-QVjlcy3u1zAETz-_b_td7069TyOClPfYM4k=@pm.me> <4115226B-2FD5-4C69-B3D0-9A3401DFC684@gewt.net> Message-ID: <4ec09d2d-d6c7-4928-b837-43dce03ee449@bitsavers.org> On 11/9/26 11:58 AM, Madeline Autumn-Rose via TUHS wrote: > I need several of these for some actual telecoms systems, amazing, there are still calls being answered by otters From tuhs at tuhs.org Tue Nov 10 06:15:52 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Dave Horsfall via TUHS) Date: Tue, 10 Nov 2026 07:15:52 +1100 Subject: [TUHS] Intuity and Audix From Lucent? In-Reply-To: <0HfcQFINUvTN5DWy4qw6zFMCZRPITxO4SQWLqltTz-ObGoArBIUKN29w0Z_BPl8t65Rk27G-QVjlcy3u1zAETz-_b_td7069TyOClPfYM4k=@pm.me> References: <0HfcQFINUvTN5DWy4qw6zFMCZRPITxO4SQWLqltTz-ObGoArBIUKN29w0Z_BPl8t65Rk27G-QVjlcy3u1zAETz-_b_td7069TyOClPfYM4k=@pm.me> Message-ID: Good luck in reading 'em; their rubber rollers tend to liquify over time... -- Dave On Tue, 10 Nov 2026 at 06:31, Cody Logan via TUHS wrote: > Related, there's a set of QIC tapes containing Intuity/Audix software up > for sale on eBay right now: https://www.ebay.com/itm/235936619065 > > On Monday, November 9th, 2026 at 9:16 AM, Kevin Bowling via TUHS < > tuhs at tuhs.org> wrote: > > > On Fri, Nov 6, 2026 at 7:34 PM segaloco via TUHS wrote: > > > > > > I've just archived a set of five Lucent Technologies 1.44MB floppy > disks > > > labeled INTUITY R4 and subtitled AUDIX R4.3/R4.4, with labels > indicating > > > UnixWare boot and emergency diskettes along with a Pentium HBA driver. > > > > > > https://archive.org/details/unixware-for-intuity-r4 > > > > > > I don't really know anything about this other than it's late UNIX stuff > > > from Lucent, so piqued my interest when I saw the disks for sale. The > > > dumps are simple dd rips of the floppy disks. > > > > From what I have seen these were voicemail appliances that connected > > to a PBX. They used standard PC hardware on a large PICMG backplane > > with many ISA slots for TDM boards that interfaced the voice calls to > > the voicemail software. A fairly common 1990s computer telephony > > setup. > > > > There is a decent chance these are standard UnixWare boot disks, in > > that case, you can go get the full media kit already on archive.org > > and elsewhere. > > > > > I haven't done any analysis of the images yet, just wanted to get them > > > dumped and uploaded. If anyone knows more about this stuff, I'd > > > certainly appreciate a second set of eyes. In any case when I've got a > > > bit more time (on the way out the door) I plan on digging around the > > > data contained within. A cursory glance reveals readable strings > > > throughout so I suspect the dumps are good. > > > > > > - Matt G. > > From tuhs at tuhs.org Tue Nov 10 07:45:59 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (segaloco via TUHS) Date: Mon, 09 Nov 2026 21:45:59 +0000 Subject: [TUHS] Intuity and Audix From Lucent? In-Reply-To: <4115226B-2FD5-4C69-B3D0-9A3401DFC684@gewt.net> References: <0HfcQFINUvTN5DWy4qw6zFMCZRPITxO4SQWLqltTz-ObGoArBIUKN29w0Z_BPl8t65Rk27G-QVjlcy3u1zAETz-_b_td7069TyOClPfYM4k=@pm.me> <4115226B-2FD5-4C69-B3D0-9A3401DFC684@gewt.net> Message-ID: On Monday, November 9th, 2026 at 11:58, Madeline Autumn-Rose via TUHS wrote: > I need several of these for some actual telecoms systems, anyone mind if pick these up? Imaging planned or would loan them for imaging. > > > On Nov 9, 2026, at 11:31, Cody Logan via TUHS wrote: > > > > Related, there's a set of QIC tapes containing Intuity/Audix software up for sale on eBay right now: https://www.ebay.com/itm/235936619065 > > I certainly won't fight anyone for QIC tapes these days. I've got my box of BTL stuff I'm sitting on, I doubt I'm making any moves on QIC tape archival any time soon, so go nuts. - Matt G. From tuhs at tuhs.org Tue Nov 10 15:44:07 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Folkert van Heusden via TUHS) Date: Tue, 10 Nov 2026 06:44:07 +0100 Subject: [TUHS] Intuity and Audix From Lucent? In-Reply-To: References: <0HfcQFINUvTN5DWy4qw6zFMCZRPITxO4SQWLqltTz-ObGoArBIUKN29w0Z_BPl8t65Rk27G-QVjlcy3u1zAETz-_b_td7069TyOClPfYM4k=@pm.me> Message-ID: <3e7d8e1c4bc957ef5d6130076a27e41b@vanheusden.com> Does anyone have the audio samples from Audix for me? thanks ("Welcome to Audix, for help at any time press *#" etc.) From tuhs at tuhs.org Tue Nov 10 21:56:22 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Cameron Tyre via TUHS) Date: Tue, 10 Nov 2026 11:56:22 +0000 Subject: [TUHS] Intuity and Audix From Lucent? In-Reply-To: <3e7d8e1c4bc957ef5d6130076a27e41b@vanheusden.com> References: <0HfcQFINUvTN5DWy4qw6zFMCZRPITxO4SQWLqltTz-ObGoArBIUKN29w0Z_BPl8t65Rk27G-QVjlcy3u1zAETz-_b_td7069TyOClPfYM4k=@pm.me> <3e7d8e1c4bc957ef5d6130076a27e41b@vanheusden.com> Message-ID: <8OYuX6iejvMRfXWFKKZIw42yK5hJwMy3USy76LnE3aiYifQZsPLKd8yGDkUoMGjnvoUwLA1xCjAd15Mz_lc19z3_ePOM73GNiBGtcIVKFdo=@protonmail.ch> Hi Folkert, Sent the little I have, off group. Best wishes, Cameron Tyre Sent from Proton Mail for Android. -------- Original Message -------- On Tuesday, 11/10/26 at 05:44 Folkert van Heusden via TUHS wrote: Does anyone have the audio samples from Audix for me? thanks ("Welcome to Audix, for help at any time press *#" etc.) From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 12 04:58:12 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Charles H Sauer (he/him) via TUHS) Date: Wed, 11 Nov 2026 12:58:12 -0600 Subject: [TUHS] UNIX ZOO Message-ID: Antoni Sawicki (aka Tenox) continues to unearth old binaries and make them easily accessible in emulators at https://unixzoo.com/ Last night I experienced AIX 3 for the first time (I left IBM in 1989, thinking that AIX 3 would ship way behind schedule and the RS/6000 hardware would be RT/PC deja vu, late and not competitive. I was right about the schedule, but I underestimated the hardware...) Charlie -- voice: +1.512.784.7526 e-mail: sauer at technologists.com fax: +1.512.346.5240 Web: https://technologists.com/sauer/ Facebook/Google/LinkedIn/mas.to: CharlesHSauer From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 12 07:46:13 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (segaloco via TUHS) Date: Wed, 11 Nov 2026 21:46:13 +0000 Subject: [TUHS] UNIX ZOO In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: On Wednesday, November 11th, 2026 at 10:58, Charles H Sauer (he/him) via TUHS wrote: > Antoni Sawicki (aka Tenox) continues to unearth old binaries and make > them easily accessible in emulators at https://unixzoo.com/ > > Last night I experienced AIX 3 for the first time (I left IBM in 1989, > thinking that AIX 3 would ship way behind schedule and the RS/6000 > hardware would be RT/PC deja vu, late and not competitive. I was right > about the schedule, but I underestimated the hardware...) > > Charlie > -- > voice: +1.512.784.7526 e-mail: sauer at technologists.com > fax: +1.512.346.5240 Web: https://technologists.com/sauer/ > Facebook/Google/LinkedIn/mas.to: CharlesHSauer > > This is so cool! I might reach out to see what it'd take to get a Sony NEWS MIPS example setup. There was an archive of several NEWS systems from Nintendo in the early '90s leaked online years ago that contained, among other things, the X11 CAD applications they had designed for drawing character tiles for the Super Nintendo. I've done some minimal disassembly of the objects to figure out bits about their X11 environment but have not successfully bootstrapped a working NEWS environment to see if they still run. I don't think these tools have been documented at all, and I'd love to be able to shed some light on how Nintendo produced their PPU graphics in this era. - Matt G. From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 12 09:50:30 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Jon Forrest via TUHS) Date: Wed, 11 Nov 2026 15:50:30 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] System Industries Message-ID: All this talk about Able Computer and Ken Omohundro reminded me of another similar company, System Industries. I used to do business with them a lot since their RP06-compatible disk drive and other DEC-compatible products were very competitive with DEC's prices. I learned a lot about how to deal with aggressive salespeople by my contacts with Bob Goetz, their VP of Sales (I think). On the other hand, the field service person assign to UC Santa Barbara, (Frank ?), was excellent. I looked like he had just come from a biker bar, and he'd read Easy Rider magazine while waiting for a disk to format. He kept a knife in his boot just in case something came up. I heard that at one time SI threatened to fire him if he didn't clean up his act, but a bunch of the customers he serviced told SI that they wouldn't buy any more SI stuff if Frank was fired. Anybody have any other SI stories? Cordially, Jon Forrest From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 12 11:40:00 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Kevin Bowling via TUHS) Date: Wed, 11 Nov 2026 18:40:00 -0700 Subject: [TUHS] UNIX ZOO In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: On Wed, Nov 11, 2026 at 11:58 AM Charles H Sauer (he/him) via TUHS wrote: > > Antoni Sawicki (aka Tenox) continues to unearth old binaries and make > them easily accessible in emulators at https://unixzoo.com/ > > Last night I experienced AIX 3 for the first time (I left IBM in 1989, > thinking that AIX 3 would ship way behind schedule and the RS/6000 > hardware would be RT/PC deja vu, late and not competitive. I was right > about the schedule, but I underestimated the hardware...) Considering its release date, AIX 3 is a pretty sophisticated UNIX OS, particularly the LVM and JFS. > Charlie > -- > voice: +1.512.784.7526 e-mail: sauer at technologists.com > fax: +1.512.346.5240 Web: https://technologists.com/sauer/ > Facebook/Google/LinkedIn/mas.to: CharlesHSauer > From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 12 11:48:15 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Adam Koszek via TUHS) Date: Wed, 11 Nov 2026 17:48:15 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? Message-ID: Hi, Has the development of systems at IBM been completely separated from the UNIX world and vice-versa? This question is inspired by a visit to Costco. They still seem to use AS/400, and I often wondered: it’s black background, white letters (very UNIXish), but e.g.: text user interface being interactive is very different from UNIX approach to command line. When I reflect back on books on UNIX, I can’t even think of a tool that’s more like TUI until someone showed me “mc” (midnight commander) This difference for me started with UX, but it's inside of the OS too. From “Inside AS/400” I learnt it had vastly different abstractions and layers of the OS, including having a ops interpreter; they knew it’ll run for a long time and weird places, so it seemed to be built to last. Adam -- Adam Koszek adam at koszek.com https://www.koszek.com From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 12 12:06:30 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Tom Lyon via TUHS) Date: Wed, 11 Nov 2026 18:06:30 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: There's a good book I recently read about the development of the AS/400: https://www.abebooks.com/9780195067545/Silverlake-Project-Transformation-IBM-Bauer-0195067541/plp (Not much tech detail, but lots of business stories) Given it's origins in the mid 70s, I doubt any UNIX influence. But - smells strongly of Multics to me - single huge address space for everything. On Wed, Nov 11, 2026 at 5:49 PM Adam Koszek via TUHS wrote: > Hi, > > Has the development of systems at IBM been completely separated from the > UNIX world and vice-versa? > > This question is inspired by a visit to Costco. They still seem to use > AS/400, and I often wondered: it’s black background, white letters (very > UNIXish), but e.g.: text user interface being interactive is very different > from UNIX approach to command line. When I reflect back on books on UNIX, I > can’t even think of a tool that’s more like TUI until someone showed me > “mc” (midnight commander) > > This difference for me started with UX, but it's inside of the OS too. > From “Inside AS/400” I learnt it had vastly different abstractions and > layers of the OS, including having a ops interpreter; they knew it’ll run > for a long time and weird places, so it seemed to be built to last. > > Adam > -- > Adam Koszek > adam at koszek.com > https://www.koszek.com > > > > From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 12 12:12:13 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (John Levine via TUHS) Date: 11 Nov 2026 21:12:13 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: <20261112021214.3AD671282D040@ary.qy> It appears that Adam Koszek via TUHS said: >Hi, > >Has the development of systems at IBM been completely separated from the UNIX world and vice-versa? No. The current incarnation of AS/400 is called IBM i. It's techically quite interesting. It has a single level store with an integrated database, and a virtual machine language called TIMI that has been hosted on widely varying physical processors, most recently Power. You can take a compiled program and move it to a new i system with a different CPU and it just works, with a short delay the first time you run it while it compiles the TIMI to native machine code. Even though its history is quite separate from Unix, there is PASE which is an AIX application environment that runs on top of i, so you can run pretty much any Unix program you want. See https://www.mcpressonline.com/operating-systems/ibm-i-os400-i5os/exploring-open-source-on-ibm-i-the-pase-environment From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 12 12:14:05 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (John Levine via TUHS) Date: 11 Nov 2026 21:14:05 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> It appears that Tom Lyon via TUHS said: >There's a good book I recently read about the development of the AS/400: >https://www.abebooks.com/9780195067545/Silverlake-Project-Transformation-IBM-Bauer-0195067541/plp >(Not much tech detail, but lots of business stories) > >Given it's origins in the mid 70s, I doubt any UNIX influence. But - >smells strongly of Multics to me - single huge address space for everything. Mot really. Multics was segmented, i has a large flat address space full of objects. I gather that S/38 and AS/400 were salvaged from the failed Future Systems project that was supposed to repalce S/360. And there's PASE, a full Unix environment on top of i. > >On Wed, Nov 11, 2026 at 5:49 PM Adam Koszek via TUHS wrote: > >> Hi, >> >> Has the development of systems at IBM been completely separated from the >> UNIX world and vice-versa? >> >> This question is inspired by a visit to Costco. They still seem to use >> AS/400, and I often wondered: it’s black background, white letters (very >> UNIXish), but e.g.: text user interface being interactive is very different >> from UNIX approach to command line. When I reflect back on books on UNIX, I >> can’t even think of a tool that’s more like TUI until someone showed me >> “mc” (midnight commander) >> >> This difference for me started with UX, but it's inside of the OS too. >> From “Inside AS/400” I learnt it had vastly different abstractions and >> layers of the OS, including having a ops interpreter; they knew it’ll run >> for a long time and weird places, so it seemed to be built to last. From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 12 13:22:57 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Kevin Bowling via TUHS) Date: Wed, 11 Nov 2026 20:22:57 -0700 Subject: [TUHS] AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> Message-ID: On Wed, Nov 11, 2026 at 7:15 PM John Levine via TUHS wrote: > > It appears that Tom Lyon via TUHS said: > >There's a good book I recently read about the development of the AS/400: > >https://www.abebooks.com/9780195067545/Silverlake-Project-Transformation-IBM-Bauer-0195067541/plp > >(Not much tech detail, but lots of business stories) > > > >Given it's origins in the mid 70s, I doubt any UNIX influence. But - > >smells strongly of Multics to me - single huge address space for everything. > > Mot really. Multics was segmented, i has a large flat address space full of objects. > I gather that S/38 and AS/400 were salvaged from the failed Future Systems project > that was supposed to repalce S/360. > > And there's PASE, a full Unix environment on top of i. > > > > >On Wed, Nov 11, 2026 at 5:49 PM Adam Koszek via TUHS wrote: > > > >> Hi, > >> > >> Has the development of systems at IBM been completely separated from the > >> UNIX world and vice-versa? > >> > >> This question is inspired by a visit to Costco. They still seem to use > >> AS/400, and I often wondered: it’s black background, white letters (very > >> UNIXish), but e.g.: text user interface being interactive is very different > >> from UNIX approach to command line. When I reflect back on books on UNIX, I > >> can’t even think of a tool that’s more like TUI until someone showed me > >> “mc” (midnight commander) > >> > >> This difference for me started with UX, but it's inside of the OS too. > >> From “Inside AS/400” I learnt it had vastly different abstractions and > >> layers of the OS, including having a ops interpreter; they knew it’ll run > >> for a long time and weird places, so it seemed to be built to last. Yes on FCS lineage. As for unix, the answer depends completely on when. Prior to mid 1990s, it was pretty clearly its own thing (until about V3) and I recall reading (maybe in one of the earlier editions of Frank Soltis book?) that they tried to staff development with people not indoctrinated in unix. PASE obviously changes things but it came about later and is still grafted on the side, metaphorically similar to the z/OS posix environment. There was a gradual merging of products: AS/400 and RS/6000 hardware slowly converged over about a decade.. first with PowerPC but Rochester had its own PowerPC AS chips for a while and the systems and firmware were incompatible. pHyp, the native LPAR hypervisor came mainly from the AS/400 side. POWER4 converged the CPU and pHyp, and by POWER5 the rest of the hardware was nearly identical and could run AIX, Linux, and i. The most unique aspect of the terminal experience, whether AS/400 5250 or mainframe 3270, is block mode vs char mode of unix. From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 12 14:40:08 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (steve jenkin via TUHS) Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 15:40:08 +1100 Subject: [TUHS] AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> Message-ID: <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> > On 12 Nov 2026, at 13:14, John Levine via TUHS wrote: > > It appears that Tom Lyon via TUHS > said: >> ... >> Given it's origins in the mid 70s, I doubt any UNIX influence. But - >> smells strongly of Multics to me - single huge address space for everything. > > Not really. Multics was segmented, i has a large flat address space full of objects. > I gather that S/38 and AS/400 were salvaged from the failed Future Systems project > that was supposed to repalce S/360. > > And there's PASE, a full Unix environment on top of i. S/38 & AS/400 used some Multics concepts quite uniquely. I did a summer job on System/34 once [ popular small accounting machine, later S/36 ] then had to deal with System/38 a few times. Each time I had to use a variant of RPG. System/38 were very popular in business and Libraries (!) - they came with a native database. And didn't need a Systems Admin, just a somewhat trained user. S/38 had two distinctive features: - loadable instruction sets per Application [ microcode sets ] - very large (48-bit) virtual memory. Everything, including files, was an object in Virtual Memory. A few times I was around S/38 or AS/400 the 48-bit VM space was exhausted and they required reboot. The VM Segments were never reused. The System/36 and System/38 lines were merged into the AS/400. [ Then the AS/400 evolved... Didn't track i & p series ] AS/400 Objects & Single-level Store S/38 The AS/400 kept the native database and 'everything an object', though seemed to have moved to a 64-bit Virtual Address. Another S/38 or AS/400 'feature' was a dealing with problems during a scheduled power-down then restart. A datacentre 3-phase was upgraded and two-phases were swapped, which caused some 3-phase motors to turn backwards [ killed some Univac disk drives ] with an emergency power-down of *everything*, [ "hit the big red button" ] including the AS/400, while it was restarting - before it had fully counted it's fingers & toes. The AS/400 decided the database indexes must be corrupt due to the power-fail, so automatically rebuilt all indexes when power was eventually restored. The power was restored by 5PM on a Sunday, the indexes took until close of business Wednesday to rebuild. In the interim, the whole of the Library system was unavailable - they couldn't even login I believe. [ A public library system that did a lot more than the catalogue ] I had a clutch of SUN systems caught up in this power outage. Don't recall we lost any systems or components. Our fsck's didn't take three days to finish :) There was another time in the same datacentre, which always ran off a UPS, never direct mains power or diesels, where a sparkie ignored a prominent notice in the distribution board and disconnected a ground wire, which the UPS relied upon to detect current leakage. It wasn't a clean 'power off', the UPS went up and down multiple times over a few seconds. That blew up multiple bits of kit, including their main CISCO router - unsure if duplicated or not. They had a 3-hr response service contract with CISCO, who got the part down from Sydney and installed in good time - kudos to them. The AS/400 survived that debacle from memory. A bunch of other systems & networking kit didn't fare well. -- Steve Jenkin, IT Systems and Design 0412 786 915 (+61 412 786 915) PO Box 38, Kippax ACT 2615, AUSTRALIA mailto:sjenkin at canb.auug.org.au http://members.tip.net.au/~sjenkin From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 12 14:40:08 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (steve jenkin via TUHS) Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 15:40:08 +1100 Subject: [TUHS] AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> Message-ID: <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> > On 12 Nov 2026, at 13:14, John Levine via TUHS wrote: > > It appears that Tom Lyon via TUHS > said: >> ... >> Given it's origins in the mid 70s, I doubt any UNIX influence. But - >> smells strongly of Multics to me - single huge address space for everything. > > Not really. Multics was segmented, i has a large flat address space full of objects. > I gather that S/38 and AS/400 were salvaged from the failed Future Systems project > that was supposed to repalce S/360. > > And there's PASE, a full Unix environment on top of i. S/38 & AS/400 used some Multics concepts quite uniquely. I did a summer job on System/34 once [ popular small accounting machine, later S/36 ] then had to deal with System/38 a few times. Each time I had to use a variant of RPG. System/38 were very popular in business and Libraries (!) - they came with a native database. And didn't need a Systems Admin, just a somewhat trained user. S/38 had two distinctive features: - loadable instruction sets per Application [ microcode sets ] - very large (48-bit) virtual memory. Everything, including files, was an object in Virtual Memory. A few times I was around S/38 or AS/400 the 48-bit VM space was exhausted and they required reboot. The VM Segments were never reused. The System/36 and System/38 lines were merged into the AS/400. [ Then the AS/400 evolved... Didn't track i & p series ] AS/400 Objects & Single-level Store S/38 The AS/400 kept the native database and 'everything an object', though seemed to have moved to a 64-bit Virtual Address. Another S/38 or AS/400 'feature' was a dealing with problems during a scheduled power-down then restart. A datacentre 3-phase was upgraded and two-phases were swapped, which caused some 3-phase motors to turn backwards [ killed some Univac disk drives ] with an emergency power-down of *everything*, [ "hit the big red button" ] including the AS/400, while it was restarting - before it had fully counted it's fingers & toes. The AS/400 decided the database indexes must be corrupt due to the power-fail, so automatically rebuilt all indexes when power was eventually restored. The power was restored by 5PM on a Sunday, the indexes took until close of business Wednesday to rebuild. In the interim, the whole of the Library system was unavailable - they couldn't even login I believe. [ A public library system that did a lot more than the catalogue ] I had a clutch of SUN systems caught up in this power outage. Don't recall we lost any systems or components. Our fsck's didn't take three days to finish :) There was another time in the same datacentre, which always ran off a UPS, never direct mains power or diesels, where a sparkie ignored a prominent notice in the distribution board and disconnected a ground wire, which the UPS relied upon to detect current leakage. It wasn't a clean 'power off', the UPS went up and down multiple times over a few seconds. That blew up multiple bits of kit, including their main CISCO router - unsure if duplicated or not. They had a 3-hr response service contract with CISCO, who got the part down from Sydney and installed in good time - kudos to them. The AS/400 survived that debacle from memory. A bunch of other systems & networking kit didn't fare well. -- Steve Jenkin, IT Systems and Design 0412 786 915 (+61 412 786 915) PO Box 38, Kippax ACT 2615, AUSTRALIA mailto:sjenkin at canb.auug.org.au http://members.tip.net.au/~sjenkin From tuhs at tuhs.org Thu Nov 12 16:49:09 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Lars Brinkhoff via TUHS) Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 06:49:09 +0000 Subject: [TUHS] AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> (John Levine via TUHS's message of "11 Nov 2026 21:14:05 -0500") References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> Message-ID: <7wmrreo87u.fsf@junk.nocrew.org> John Levine wrote: > Tom Lyon wrote: >> Given it's origins in the mid 70s, I doubt any UNIX influence. But >> [AS/400] smells strongly of Multics to me - single huge address space >> for everything. > > Mot really. Multics was segmented, i has a large flat address space > full of objects. There's also some kind of virtual machine going on inside the AS/400. The real hardware instruction set is not available to customers. Also some other oddities I don't remember. I gather it's really quite different from most everything else. Think different! [*] * Jokingly referring to Apple marketing looking down on IBM. From tuhs at tuhs.org Fri Nov 13 00:33:34 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Charles H Sauer (he/him) via TUHS) Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 08:33:34 -0600 Subject: [TUHS] AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> Message-ID: <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> Discussion of AS/400 probably belongs in COFF. Contemplation of AS/400 should begin with its initial instantiation, the System/38 -- see https://bitsavers.org/pdf/ibm/system38/IBM_System_38_Technical_Developments_Dec1978.pdf. IBM largely precluded employees' involvement with Unix until well after the System/38 was released, so it wasn't until many years later that there was significant influence of Unix on the AS/400. Glenn Henry was the principal person behind the System/38. IBM would not have succeeded in the Unix business without Glenn's impetus after moving from Rochester to Austin, after finishing his work with the System/38. Glenn instigated and led the development of what became the RT/PC and AIX. Without the RT and associated AIX experience, IBM likely would not have developed (or succeeded with) the RS/6000, PowerPC et al Glenn has been working on a memoir "Computers I Have Known" -- see https://www.glennsmuseum.com/intro.pdf and Glenn's LinkedIn posts. Though the planned chapter on the 38 is not yet visible to my knowledge, at https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7510106472228265984/, Glenn says "Keeping this project alive and getting it shipped while retaining its advanced and unique technical features (high-level object-oriented machine interface, single-level storage with 48b addressing, integrated relational database, etc.) in spite of heavy resistance from the “establishment” was the hardest job I have ever done, and the one I am still most proud of." I'm also working on a memoir at https://technologists.com/GMT2M/. It is relatively complete through 1995 (with outline and snippets for subsequent years) and discusses working for Glenn at IBM and Dell. Charlie On 11/11/2026 10:40 PM, steve jenkin via TUHS wrote: > >> On 12 Nov 2026, at 13:14, John Levine via TUHS wrote: >> >> It appears that Tom Lyon via TUHS > said: >>> ... > >>> Given it's origins in the mid 70s, I doubt any UNIX influence. But - >>> smells strongly of Multics to me - single huge address space for everything. >> >> Not really. Multics was segmented, i has a large flat address space full of objects. >> I gather that S/38 and AS/400 were salvaged from the failed Future Systems project >> that was supposed to repalce S/360. >> >> And there's PASE, a full Unix environment on top of i. > > S/38 & AS/400 used some Multics concepts quite uniquely. > > I did a summer job on System/34 once [ popular small accounting machine, later S/36 ] > then had to deal with System/38 a few times. > Each time I had to use a variant of RPG. > > System/38 were very popular in business and Libraries (!) - they came with a native database. > And didn't need a Systems Admin, just a somewhat trained user. > > S/38 had two distinctive features: > > - loadable instruction sets per Application [ microcode sets ] > - very large (48-bit) virtual memory. > > Everything, including files, was an object in Virtual Memory. > A few times I was around S/38 or AS/400 the 48-bit VM space was exhausted > and they required reboot. The VM Segments were never reused. > > The System/36 and System/38 lines were merged into the AS/400. > [ Then the AS/400 evolved... Didn't track i & p series ] > > AS/400 Objects & Single-level Store > > > S/38 > > > The AS/400 kept the native database and 'everything an object', > though seemed to have moved to a 64-bit Virtual Address. > > Another S/38 or AS/400 'feature' was a dealing with problems during a scheduled power-down then restart. > > A datacentre 3-phase was upgraded and two-phases were swapped, > which caused some 3-phase motors to turn backwards [ killed some Univac disk drives ] > with an emergency power-down of *everything*, [ "hit the big red button" ] > including the AS/400, while it was restarting - before it had fully counted it's fingers & toes. > > The AS/400 decided the database indexes must be corrupt due to the power-fail, > so automatically rebuilt all indexes when power was eventually restored. > > The power was restored by 5PM on a Sunday, the indexes took until close of business Wednesday to rebuild. > In the interim, the whole of the Library system was unavailable - they couldn't even login I believe. > [ A public library system that did a lot more than the catalogue ] > > I had a clutch of SUN systems caught up in this power outage. > Don't recall we lost any systems or components. Our fsck's didn't take three days to finish :) > > There was another time in the same datacentre, which always ran off a UPS, never direct mains power or diesels, > where a sparkie ignored a prominent notice in the distribution board > and disconnected a ground wire, which the UPS relied upon to detect current leakage. > > It wasn't a clean 'power off', the UPS went up and down multiple times over a few seconds. > That blew up multiple bits of kit, including their main CISCO router - unsure if duplicated or not. > They had a 3-hr response service contract with CISCO, > who got the part down from Sydney and installed in good time - kudos to them. > > The AS/400 survived that debacle from memory. A bunch of other systems & networking kit didn't fare well. > > > -- > Steve Jenkin, IT Systems and Design > 0412 786 915 (+61 412 786 915) > PO Box 38, Kippax ACT 2615, AUSTRALIA > > mailto:sjenkin at canb.auug.org.au http://members.tip.net.au/~sjenkin -- voice: +1.512.784.7526 e-mail: sauer at technologists.com fax: +1.512.346.5240 Web: https://technologists.com/sauer/ Facebook/Google/LinkedIn/mas.to: CharlesHSauer From tuhs at tuhs.org Fri Nov 13 06:31:15 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Clem Cole via TUHS) Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 15:31:15 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> Message-ID: WRT AS/400 and Unix. There are good stories here: After dominating the education business with S/360 in the late 1960s, DEC pretty much cornered that market. One message received from their customers that IBM sales used was to convince IBM management to build some sort of Unix offering to target education, which became AIX/370. Charlie knows more of the details, but IBM's management hired the Los Angeles-based Locus Computing Corp (LCC) to help. Heinz can also color here, as I think his team at ISC had an even earlier version of AIX/370 before LCC was contracted. I'm also not sure if that work shipped as an IBM product. The LCC work resulted in AIX/370 and AIX/PS2 (386 micro channel system). As I have mentioned before, one of the really cool features was that a user could build a single system image computer and even mix 360/370 and Intel ISA [ called the transparent computing facility for TCF]. For transparency in this answer, I later became a senior scientist at LCC in the Boston office. I did not directly work on the IBM project, although I was extremely familiar with its replacement, TNC - Transparent Network Computing. At LCC, most of the AIX development was done in LA. Please understand, at the time LCC was a very small firm (less than 100 - 150 people) and was building complete systems or systems for all of the major Unix players (DEC, DG, HP, Apollo, Bulle, Nixdorf, and the like). Our external legal counsel once remarked to my boss while we were working on a contract (in this case with DEC for the Cluster File System that went into TruClusters): "*for such a small firm, you guys have incredible legal needs*." But due to the original AIX work, we thought we had a solid boilerplate to forward by amending the core contract with a new 'statement of work' (SOW) that described what the customer (IBM in this case) needed. So the POSIX work is now full stream, and I think we were even out of draft when IBM Rochester, the folks that build AS/400, came to us to build a POSIX subsystem for them. So my boss got the core IBM contract we start to develop an "SOW" for the AS/400 guys. Only to be told we had to start all over again with IBM legal. I believe that words were something on the order of: "Oh no, we cannot use that contract. We need our own for Rochester. We push back and were told, "Well, we won the Baldrige Award and have all our own contracts." The point was, you discovered IBM was not one company. It's a huge clump of smaller companies that often did their own things Sent from a handheld expect more typos than usual On Thu, Nov 12, 2026 at 9:35 AM Charles H Sauer (he/him) via COFF < coff at tuhs.org> wrote: > Discussion of AS/400 probably belongs in COFF. > > Contemplation of AS/400 should begin with its initial instantiation, the > System/38 -- see > > https://bitsavers.org/pdf/ibm/system38/IBM_System_38_Technical_Developments_Dec1978.pdf. > > > > IBM largely precluded employees' involvement with Unix until well after > the System/38 was released, so it wasn't until many years later that > there was significant influence of Unix on the AS/400. > > Glenn Henry was the principal person behind the System/38. IBM would not > have succeeded in the Unix business without Glenn's impetus after moving > from Rochester to Austin, after finishing his work with the System/38. > Glenn instigated and led the development of what became the RT/PC and > AIX. Without the RT and associated AIX experience, IBM likely would not > have developed (or succeeded with) the RS/6000, PowerPC et al > > Glenn has been working on a memoir "Computers I Have Known" -- see > https://www.glennsmuseum.com/intro.pdf and Glenn's LinkedIn posts. > Though the planned chapter on the 38 is not yet visible to my knowledge, > at > https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7510106472228265984/, > > Glenn says "Keeping this project alive and getting it shipped while > retaining its advanced and unique technical features (high-level > object-oriented machine interface, single-level storage with 48b > addressing, integrated relational database, etc.) in spite of heavy > resistance from the “establishment” was the hardest job I have ever > done, and the one I am still most proud of." > > I'm also working on a memoir at https://technologists.com/GMT2M/. It is > relatively complete through 1995 (with outline and snippets for > subsequent years) and discusses working for Glenn at IBM and Dell. > > Charlie > > On 11/11/2026 10:40 PM, steve jenkin via TUHS wrote: > > > >> On 12 Nov 2026, at 13:14, John Levine via TUHS wrote: > >> > >> It appears that Tom Lyon via TUHS pugs78 at gmail.com>> said: > >>> ... > > > >>> Given it's origins in the mid 70s, I doubt any UNIX influence. But - > >>> smells strongly of Multics to me - single huge address space for > everything. > >> > >> Not really. Multics was segmented, i has a large flat address space > full of objects. > >> I gather that S/38 and AS/400 were salvaged from the failed Future > Systems project > >> that was supposed to repalce S/360. > >> > >> And there's PASE, a full Unix environment on top of i. > > > > S/38 & AS/400 used some Multics concepts quite uniquely. > > > > I did a summer job on System/34 once [ popular small accounting machine, > later S/36 ] > > then had to deal with System/38 a few times. > > Each time I had to use a variant of RPG. > > > > System/38 were very popular in business and Libraries (!) - they came > with a native database. > > And didn't need a Systems Admin, just a somewhat trained user. > > > > S/38 had two distinctive features: > > > > - loadable instruction sets per Application [ microcode sets ] > > - very large (48-bit) virtual memory. > > > > Everything, including files, was an object in Virtual Memory. > > A few times I was around S/38 or AS/400 the 48-bit VM space was exhausted > > and they required reboot. The VM Segments were never reused. > > > > The System/36 and System/38 lines were merged into the AS/400. > > [ Then the AS/400 evolved... Didn't track i & p series ] > > > > AS/400 Objects & Single-level Store > > < > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_AS/400#Object-based_design> > > > > S/38 > > > > > > The AS/400 kept the native database and 'everything an object', > > though seemed to have moved to a 64-bit Virtual Address. > > > > Another S/38 or AS/400 'feature' was a dealing with problems during a > scheduled power-down then restart. > > > > A datacentre 3-phase was upgraded and two-phases were swapped, > > which caused some 3-phase motors to turn backwards [ killed some Univac > disk drives ] > > with an emergency power-down of *everything*, [ "hit the big red button" > ] > > including the AS/400, while it was restarting - before it had fully > counted it's fingers & toes. > > > > The AS/400 decided the database indexes must be corrupt due to the > power-fail, > > so automatically rebuilt all indexes when power was eventually restored. > > > > The power was restored by 5PM on a Sunday, the indexes took until close > of business Wednesday to rebuild. > > In the interim, the whole of the Library system was unavailable - they > couldn't even login I believe. > > [ A public library system that did a lot more than the catalogue ] > > > > I had a clutch of SUN systems caught up in this power outage. > > Don't recall we lost any systems or components. Our fsck's didn't take > three days to finish :) > > > > There was another time in the same datacentre, which always ran off a > UPS, never direct mains power or diesels, > > where a sparkie ignored a prominent notice in the distribution board > > and disconnected a ground wire, which the UPS relied upon to detect > current leakage. > > > > It wasn't a clean 'power off', the UPS went up and down multiple times > over a few seconds. > > That blew up multiple bits of kit, including their main CISCO router - > unsure if duplicated or not. > > They had a 3-hr response service contract with CISCO, > > who got the part down from Sydney and installed in good time - kudos to > them. > > > > The AS/400 survived that debacle from memory. A bunch of other systems & > networking kit didn't fare well. > > > > > > -- > > Steve Jenkin, IT Systems and Design > > 0412 786 915 (+61 412 786 915 <+61%20412%20786%20915>) > > PO Box 38, Kippax ACT 2615, AUSTRALIA > > > > mailto:sjenkin at canb.auug.org.au http://members.tip.net.au/~sjenkin > > -- > voice: +1.512.784.7526 <(512)%20784-7526> e-mail: > sauer at technologists.com > fax: +1.512.346.5240 <(512)%20346-5240> Web: > https://technologists.com/sauer/ > Facebook/Google/LinkedIn/mas.to > : > CharlesHSauer > > From tuhs at tuhs.org Fri Nov 13 07:10:44 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Charles H Sauer (he/him) via TUHS) Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 15:10:44 -0600 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> Message-ID: <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> A few more points: I don't know when LCC was formed, but I think the first Locus paper was presented at SOSP in December 1981, well after S/38 released in 1978. I think Popek stayed on UCLA faculty and formed LCC after 1981. There was some Unix for the 370 before AIX/370, but I never had hands on experience with it or much knowledge of it. "AIX" didn't exist on any platform until the RT/PC first announcement in January 1986. I don't think AIX/370 was available until 1989 or later. (More about AIX history at https://notes.technologists.com/notes/2017/03/08/lets-start-at-the-very-beginning-801-romp-rtpc-aix-versions/, which Clem helped me with when I wrote it.) I don't know of any instances of AIX/370 visible today, but Antoni Sawicki's https://unixzoo.com/ has AIX PS/2 1.3, which might allow one to experience some of the Locus ("TCF") capabilities, but not the ones across processor architectures. I don't think AS/400 had any Unix associated capabilities yet when I left IBM in 1989. Before I left, I helped negotiate an NFS license to include all of IBM platforms, not just "real" Unix platforms. My impression is that AS/400 gained NFS and the POSIX subsystem Clem cites in the 1990s. On 11/12/2026 2:31 PM, Clem Cole wrote: > WRT AS/400 and Unix.  There are good stories here: > > After dominating the education business with S/360 in the late 1960s, > DEC pretty much cornered that market.  One messagereceived from their > customers that IBM sales used was to convince IBM management to build > some sort of Unix offering to target education, which became AIX/370. > > Charlie knows more of the details, but IBM's management hired the Los > Angeles-based Locus Computing Corp (LCC) to help.  Heinz can also color > here, as I think his team at ISC had an even earlier version of AIX/370 > before LCC was contracted.  I'm also not sure if that work shipped as an > IBM product. > > The LCC work resulted in AIX/370 and AIX/PS2 (386 micro channel system). >   As I have mentioned before, one of the really cool features was that > a user could build a single system image computer and even mix 360/370 > and Intel ISA [ called the transparent computing facilityfor TCF]. > > For transparencyin this answer, I later became a senior scientist at LCC > in the Boston office. I did not directly work on the IBM project, > although I was extremely familiar with its replacement, TNC - > Transparent Network Computing.At LCC, most of the AIX development was > done in LA. > > Pleaseunderstand, at the time LCC was a very small firm (less than 100 - > 150 people) and was building complete systems or systems for all of the > major Unix players (DEC, DG, HP, Apollo, Bulle, Nixdorf, and the like). > Our external legal counsel once remarked to my boss while we > were working on a contract (in this case with DEC for the Cluster File > System that went into TruClusters):"/for such a small firm, you guys > have incredible legal needs/." > > But due to the original AIX work, we thought we had a solid > boilerplate to forward by amending the core contract with a new > 'statement of work' (SOW) that described what the customer (IBM in this > case) needed. > > So the POSIX work is now full stream,and I think we were even out of > draft when IBM Rochester, the folks thatbuild AS/400, came to us to > build a POSIX subsystem for them.  So my boss got the core IBM contract > we start to develop an "SOW" for the AS/400 guys.  Only to be told we > had to start all over again with IBM legal.  I believe that > words were something on the order of: "Oh no, we cannot use > that contract.   We need our own for Rochester.  We push back and were > told, "Well, we won the Baldrige Award and have all our own contracts." > > The point was, you discovered IBM was not one company.  It's a huge > clump of smaller companies that often did their own things > > > > > > Sent from a handheld expect more typos than usual > > On Thu, Nov 12, 2026 at 9:35 AM Charles H Sauer (he/him) via COFF > > wrote: > > Discussion of AS/400 probably belongs in COFF. > > Contemplation of AS/400 should begin with its initial instantiation, > the > System/38 -- see > https://bitsavers.org/pdf/ibm/system38/ > IBM_System_38_Technical_Developments_Dec1978.pdf bitsavers.org/pdf/ibm/system38/ > IBM_System_38_Technical_Developments_Dec1978.pdf>. > > > IBM largely precluded employees' involvement with Unix until well after > the System/38 was released, so it wasn't until many years later that > there was significant influence of Unix on the AS/400. > > Glenn Henry was the principal person behind the System/38. IBM would > not > have succeeded in the Unix business without Glenn's impetus after > moving > from Rochester to Austin, after finishing his work with the System/38. > Glenn instigated and led the development of what became the RT/PC and > AIX. Without the RT and associated AIX experience, IBM likely would not > have developed (or succeeded with) the RS/6000, PowerPC et al > > Glenn has been working on a memoir "Computers I Have Known" -- see > https://www.glennsmuseum.com/intro.pdf www.glennsmuseum.com/intro.pdf> and Glenn's LinkedIn posts. > Though the planned chapter on the 38 is not yet visible to my > knowledge, > at > https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/ > urn:li:activity:7510106472228265984/ update/urn:li:activity:7510106472228265984/>, > Glenn says "Keeping this project alive and getting it shipped while > retaining its advanced and unique technical features (high-level > object-oriented machine interface, single-level storage with 48b > addressing, integrated relational database, etc.) in spite of heavy > resistance from the “establishment” was the hardest job I have ever > done, and the one I am still most proud of." > > I'm also working on a memoir at https://technologists.com/GMT2M/ > . It is > relatively complete through 1995 (with outline and snippets for > subsequent years) and discusses working for Glenn at IBM and Dell. > > Charlie > > On 11/11/2026 10:40 PM, steve jenkin via TUHS wrote: > > > >> On 12 Nov 2026, at 13:14, John Levine via TUHS > wrote: > >> > >> It appears that Tom Lyon via TUHS >> said: > >>> ... > > > >>> Given it's origins in the mid 70s, I doubt any UNIX influence. > But - > >>> smells strongly of Multics to me - single huge address space > for everything. > >> > >> Not really.  Multics was segmented, i has a large flat address > space full of objects. > >> I gather that S/38 and AS/400 were salvaged from the failed > Future Systems project > >> that was supposed to repalce S/360. > >> > >> And there's PASE, a full Unix environment on top of i. > > > > S/38 & AS/400 used some Multics concepts quite uniquely. > > > > I did a summer job on System/34 once [ popular small accounting > machine, later S/36 ] > > then had to deal with System/38 a few times. > > Each time I had to use a variant of RPG. > > > > System/38 were very popular in business and Libraries (!) - they > came with a native database. > > And didn't need a Systems Admin, just a somewhat trained user. > > > > S/38 had two distinctive features: > > > >       - loadable instruction sets per Application [ microcode sets ] > >       - very large (48-bit) virtual memory. > > > > Everything, including files, was an object in Virtual Memory. > > A few times I was around S/38 or AS/400 the 48-bit VM space was > exhausted > > and they required reboot. The VM Segments were never reused. > > > > The System/36 and System/38 lines were merged into the AS/400. > > [ Then the AS/400 evolved... Didn't track i & p series ] > > > >       AS/400 Objects & Single-level Store > >                based_design based_design>> > > > >       S/38 > >                > > > > > The AS/400 kept the native database and 'everything an object', > > though seemed to have moved to a 64-bit Virtual Address. > > > > Another S/38 or AS/400 'feature' was a dealing with problems > during a scheduled power-down then restart. > > > > A datacentre 3-phase was upgraded and two-phases were swapped, > > which caused some 3-phase motors to turn backwards [ killed some > Univac disk drives ] > > with an emergency power-down of *everything*, [ "hit the big red > button" ] > > including the AS/400, while it was restarting - before it had > fully counted it's fingers & toes. > > > > The AS/400 decided the database indexes must be corrupt due to > the power-fail, > > so automatically rebuilt all indexes when power was eventually > restored. > > > > The power was restored by 5PM on a Sunday, the indexes took until > close of business Wednesday to rebuild. > > In the interim, the whole of the Library system was unavailable - > they couldn't even login I believe. > > [ A public library system that did a lot more than the catalogue ] > > > > I had a clutch of SUN systems caught up in this power outage. > > Don't recall we lost any systems or components. Our fsck's didn't > take three days to finish :) > > > > There was another time in the same datacentre, which always ran > off a UPS, never direct mains power or diesels, > > where a sparkie ignored a prominent notice in the distribution board > > and disconnected a ground wire, which the UPS relied upon to > detect current leakage. > > > > It wasn't a clean 'power off', the UPS went up and down multiple > times over a few seconds. > > That blew up multiple bits of kit, including their main CISCO > router - unsure if duplicated or not. > > They had a 3-hr response service contract with CISCO, > > who got the part down from Sydney and installed in good time - > kudos to them. > > > > The AS/400 survived that debacle from memory. A bunch of other > systems & networking kit didn't fare well. > > > > > > -- > > Steve Jenkin, IT Systems and Design > > 0412 786 915 (+61 412 786 915 ) > > PO Box 38, Kippax ACT 2615, AUSTRALIA > > > > mailto:sjenkin at canb.auug.org.au > http://members.tip.net.au/~sjenkin > > -- > voice: +1.512.784.7526        e-mail: > sauer at technologists.com > fax: +1.512.346.5240          Web: https:// > technologists.com/sauer/ > Facebook/Google/LinkedIn/mas.to Facebook/Google/LinkedIn/mas.to>: CharlesHSauer > -- voice: +1.512.784.7526 e-mail: sauer at technologists.com fax: +1.512.346.5240 Web: https://technologists.com/sauer/ Facebook/Google/LinkedIn/mas.to: CharlesHSauer From tuhs at tuhs.org Fri Nov 13 07:27:25 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (John Levine via TUHS) Date: 12 Nov 2026 16:27:25 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> Message-ID: <20261112212726.1169C12845A2A@ary.qy> It appears that Clem Cole via TUHS said: >Charlie knows more of the details, but IBM's management hired the Los >Angeles-based Locus Computing Corp (LCC) to help. Heinz can also color here, >as I think his team at ISC had an even earlier version of AIX/370 before >LCC was contracted. I'm also not sure if that work shipped as an IBM >product. I didn't work on it but I was at ISC at the time. They did a Unix port that ran on VM/370. with some extensions to VM to create lightweight virtual machines to implement Unix processes. It worked quite well but IBM declined to adopt the VM extensions so that was that. I think this was before the RT/PC project which I did work on, so AIX was not yet a thing. R's, John From tuhs at tuhs.org Fri Nov 13 07:58:40 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Clem Cole via TUHS) Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 16:58:40 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <20261112212726.1169C12845A2A@ary.qy> References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <20261112212726.1169C12845A2A@ary.qy> Message-ID: Thanks John. As I said I was pretty sure it existed but no idea of its status. With LCC's work, I think we used started with the compiler toolchain but everything else was new. ISTR that the core system was based on 4.1 and sockets were added at somepoint. Sent from a handheld expect more typos than usual On Thu, Nov 12, 2026 at 4:27 PM John Levine wrote: > It appears that Clem Cole via TUHS said: > >Charlie knows more of the details, but IBM's management hired the Los > >Angeles-based Locus Computing Corp (LCC) to help. Heinz can also color > here, > >as I think his team at ISC had an even earlier version of AIX/370 before > >LCC was contracted. I'm also not sure if that work shipped as an IBM > >product. > > I didn't work on it but I was at ISC at the time. They did a Unix port > that > ran on VM/370. with some extensions to VM to create lightweight virtual > machines > to implement Unix processes. It worked quite well but IBM declined to > adopt > the VM extensions so that was that. > > I think this was before the RT/PC project which I did work on, so AIX was > not yet a thing. > > R's, > John > From tuhs at tuhs.org Fri Nov 13 13:21:20 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (John Cowan via TUHS) Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 22:21:20 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] C from 1980 binaries In-Reply-To: References: <188ef5e9-d1c4-4acd-a6f4-e97a018abf24@xavax.com> <7.1.0.9.0.20261030133125.085d7e50@threedee.com> <56b6be1a-8253-4b30-b5b6-36177f45edfa@xavax.com> <20261026233611.1B47D1253528F@ary.qy> <20261030194928.C61F7125F8670@ary.qy> <7.1.0.9.0.20261031223227.0989ee48@threedee.com> <20261101145517.GK15589@mcvoy.com> Message-ID: Just to correct the persistent error in this thread, the Omohundro name doesn't have an apostrophe. All Omohundros and Mohundros in the U.S. descend from a common ancestor who arrived from parts unknown, probably Britain before 1670, and died in Virginia in 1697. There is no known explanation for the name: it does not appear to be English, Welsh, Scottish, Irish, Cornish, Norman French, or anything else. On Sun, Nov 1, 2026, 9:11 PM Jon Forrest via TUHS wrote: > > > On 11/1/26 5:13 PM, Clem Cole via TUHS wrote: > > > At the time, WD was working on the chipset, and DEC had won the lawsuit > it > > filed against California Data Processors (*a.k.a.* CalData). The results > of > > that lawsuit were fresh in the eyes of the team at WD [Ken O'Mohundro > and > > Fred Cox's firm cloned a number of different ISAs but chose the UNIBUS, > > which got them in trouble. O'Mohundro had famously run the complete > 11//40 > > diagnostics suite for Ken Olson at the National Computer show in > CalData's > > booth]. > Ken O'Mohundro - there's a name I haven't heard in a while. In the early > 1980s I ran the Santa Barbara VMS Users Group. At the time, there were a > few vendors who were starting to make DEC-compatible peripherals, such > as memory, and disk/communication/network controllers. One of the > vendors was Able, in Orange County, CA. Somehow Ken contacted me to > ask if he could come talk to our users group about DEC stuff. Ken > was a self-described stutterer who enjoyed addressing groups of > people as a form of speech therapy. So, he came all the way up > to Santa Barbara from Irvine and gave a nice presentation. IIRC, > Able Computer paid for lunch for everyone. > > He was a very nice guy. > > Cordially, > Jon Forrest > > From tuhs at tuhs.org Fri Nov 13 14:30:39 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Heinz Lycklama via TUHS) Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 20:30:39 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <20261112212726.1169C12845A2A@ary.qy> Message-ID: <7ebe2e51-9809-42d2-963d-6d4d2e1f60af@osta.com> Charlie's Technology Notes refreshes my memory of the time frame of the development of AIX for IBM in Austin in the mid 1980's. We (ISC)  did most of the work on this in our Boston office, which reported to me at the time. And I do believe that AIX for the RT was released in the 1988 time frame.  ISC did do some work on IBM/370 and UNIX, but I do not think we were involved in the AIX/370 system. And we were not involved in the work that LCC did for IBM later on. Heinz On 11/12/2026 1:58 PM, Clem Cole via TUHS wrote: > Thanks John. As I said I was pretty sure it existed but no idea of its > status. With LCC's work, I think we used started with the compiler > toolchain but everything else was new. ISTR that the core system was based > on 4.1 and sockets were added at somepoint. > > > Sent from a handheld expect more typos than usual > > On Thu, Nov 12, 2026 at 4:27 PM John Levine wrote: > >> It appears that Clem Cole via TUHS said: >>> Charlie knows more of the details, but IBM's management hired the Los >>> Angeles-based Locus Computing Corp (LCC) to help. Heinz can also color >> here, >>> as I think his team at ISC had an even earlier version of AIX/370 before >>> LCC was contracted. I'm also not sure if that work shipped as an IBM >>> product. >> I didn't work on it but I was at ISC at the time. They did a Unix port >> that >> ran on VM/370. with some extensions to VM to create lightweight virtual >> machines >> to implement Unix processes. It worked quite well but IBM declined to >> adopt >> the VM extensions so that was that. >> >> I think this was before the RT/PC project which I did work on, so AIX was >> not yet a thing. >> >> R's, >> John >> From tuhs at tuhs.org Fri Nov 13 17:34:16 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Brandon M. Petty via TUHS) Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 01:34:16 -0600 Subject: [TUHS] Acquired 4 Binders of early 80s ESS/SCCS UNIX Manuals In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: Matt, this find perfectly lines up with a project I am working on. I am working on a full 1A ESS simulation for a CTF game.  I've gone a little overboard with making it as full featured as possible.  One challenge has been connecting to it.  I chose to simulate a No. 2 SCCS environment.  The documentation on actually connecting to the switch, a specific office / channel, has been difficult to nail down. I would love to review these materials. If there is anything I can do to help, please let me know. I have a LOT of SCC questions I am hoping this answers a few of them, specifically around the SCC Shell. Example: |$ls /office CHI1AE13DS0 ||$M:CHI1AE13DS0.MTC! WHO-RU-. ||CHI1AE13DS0 1AE13 ... $| I want to know how accurate that is. I'd love to know all of the other system utilities that came standard. Thank you all! -Brandon P. From tuhs at tuhs.org Fri Nov 13 17:50:50 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Arnold Robbins via TUHS) Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 00:50:50 -0700 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> Message-ID: <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> "Charles H Sauer (he/him) via TUHS" wrote: > There was some Unix for the 370 before AIX/370, but I never had hands on > experience with it or much knowledge of it. IIRC, it was called IX/370. I remember that it was based on System III, and came out shortly after AT&T released System V. I remember articles in rags like InfoWorld wondering if IBM putting their weight behind System III would derail AT&T's efforts with System V. So this would be early to mid-80s, before AIX and the RT/PC. Inside the Bell System, Unix ran on the 370, and Amdahl had their own port(s), but I don't know the timelines or specifics of those. HTH, Arnold From tuhs at tuhs.org Sat Nov 14 00:10:30 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (al kossow via TUHS) Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 06:10:30 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> Message-ID: <6666a691-5d3e-47a2-af86-1fa49fe19261@bitsavers.org> On 11/12/26 11:50 PM, Arnold Robbins via TUHS wrote: > Amdahl had > their own port(s), but I don't know the timelines or specifics > of those. > Is Pugs around here? From tuhs at tuhs.org Sat Nov 14 01:14:23 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Clem Cole via TUHS) Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 10:14:23 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> Message-ID: Below Sent from a handheld expect more typos than usual On Fri, Nov 13, 2026 at 2:50 AM wrote: > "Charles H Sauer (he/him) via TUHS" wrote: > > > There was some Unix for the 370 before AIX/370, but I never had hands on > > experience with it or much knowledge of it. > > IIRC, it was called IX/370. I remember that it was based on System III, > and came out shortly after AT&T released System V. I remember articles in > rags like InfoWorld wondering if IBM putting their weight behind System > III would derail AT&T's efforts with System V. So this would be early > to mid-80s, before AIX and the RT/PC. > > Inside the Bell System, Unix ran on the 370, and Amdahl had their own > port(s), but I don't know the timelines or specifics of those. My memory of the Bell Labs Unix for the 370, was hosted in some way under TSS. But I never knew the specifics. Finding that code base for TUHS would be a nice addition. ISTR: when CMU was replacing their TSS based 360, one of the proposed solutions was to do the same; although I have no idea how serious it was. > > > HTH, > > Arnold > From tuhs at tuhs.org Sat Nov 14 02:23:36 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Adam Thornton via TUHS) Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 09:23:36 -0700 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> Message-ID: The TSS-hosted Unix is described in a 1984 paper by W.A. Felton, G.L. Miller, and J.M. Milner: "A *UNIX* System Implementation for System/370". It appears on p.1751 of the AT&T Bell Laboratories Technical Journal; I have it collected in the October 1984 Vol. 63 No. 8 Part 2 issue, which has "The UNIX System" on the cover. I don't know of anyone who has gotten this Unix running under emulation. UTS is quite easy; there's Moshix's YouTube video explaining it and once you get it running, it's just a v7 system with a nice screen editor ("ned"). It is still being developed for (sort of): cf. https://github.com/athornton/utsnap (I'm also working on a 3270 emulator that will soon, but does not yet, do both GOCA vector graphics and PS-based raster graphics (https://github.com/athornton/tn3270). The first application is to use the technique described in https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-NAT_K7ng6A to do a proper Space Invaders port. Both of these are largely vibecoded, so if that offends you, steer clear. There's a second reason a subsecond sleep driver might be useful, but that's a secret for now until I know whether the idea is even feasible. Adam On Fri, Nov 13, 2026 at 8:15 AM Clem Cole via TUHS wrote: > Below > > > Sent from a handheld expect more typos than usual > > On Fri, Nov 13, 2026 at 2:50 AM wrote: > > > "Charles H Sauer (he/him) via TUHS" wrote: > > > > > There was some Unix for the 370 before AIX/370, but I never had hands > on > > > experience with it or much knowledge of it. > > > > IIRC, it was called IX/370. I remember that it was based on System III, > > and came out shortly after AT&T released System V. I remember articles in > > rags like InfoWorld wondering if IBM putting their weight behind System > > III would derail AT&T's efforts with System V. So this would be early > > to mid-80s, before AIX and the RT/PC. > > > > Inside the Bell System, Unix ran on the 370, and Amdahl had their own > > port(s), but I don't know the timelines or specifics of those. > > My memory of the Bell Labs Unix for the 370, was hosted in some way under > TSS. But I never knew the specifics. Finding that code base for TUHS > would be a nice addition. > > ISTR: when CMU was replacing their TSS based 360, one of the proposed > solutions was to do the same; although I have no idea how serious it was. > > > > > > > HTH, > > > > Arnold > > > From tuhs at tuhs.org Sat Nov 14 08:18:36 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Peter Yardley via TUHS) Date: Sat, 14 Nov 2026 09:18:36 +1100 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> Message-ID: <94395EC5-43AC-4FAC-93BB-552F2B900888@gmail.com> Hi, At the Uni I worked for we had at one point, in the 80s in think, UTS (Universal Timesharing System) a UNIX implementation, running on VM on an Amdahl V8. AI says it was launched in 1981 and developed at Princeton and ran on IBM 360s/370s. > On 13 Nov 2026, at 6:50 pm, Arnold Robbins via TUHS wrote: > > "Charles H Sauer (he/him) via TUHS" wrote: > >> There was some Unix for the 370 before AIX/370, but I never had hands on >> experience with it or much knowledge of it. > > IIRC, it was called IX/370. I remember that it was based on System III, > and came out shortly after AT&T released System V. I remember articles in > rags like InfoWorld wondering if IBM putting their weight behind System > III would derail AT&T's efforts with System V. So this would be early > to mid-80s, before AIX and the RT/PC. > > Inside the Bell System, Unix ran on the 370, and Amdahl had > their own port(s), but I don't know the timelines or specifics > of those. > > HTH, > > Arnold .1.3.6.1.4.1.8852.4.2 Peter Yardley peter.martin.yardley at gmail.com From tuhs at tuhs.org Sat Nov 14 09:35:03 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Adam Thornton via TUHS) Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 16:35:03 -0700 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> Message-ID: Yes, "UTS under VM" is the Amdahl Unix port. I really like it, in that it has the simplicity of v7, a nice screen editor, and doesn't have the most annoying thing about v7 which is the 16-bit address space limitation. If only it had a TCP/IP implementation, it'd be just about perfect... Adam On Fri, Nov 13, 2026 at 10:10 AM Clem Cole wrote: > Cutting this way back and Cc'ing Tom. > > Adam, thank you. FWIW, I knew about the BTJ article. I think we may even > have it and the rest of the BTJ volume in the TUHS archives (I'll try to > look later when I have a real Internet connection). But I want to dig > deeper into the TSS aspect. > > Tom - do you have any insight regarding the TSS version? I've also seen > a note/email somewhere suggesting Unix for TSS leaked out of Bell Labs, but > I cannot fathom anyone but CMU would have been interested, unless it got > moved to MTS (MTS was developed when TSS was having issues. CMU decided to > fix TSS, whereas U-Mich chose to rewrite it. Many core systems functions > were the same, making it reasonable to move subsystems between them, > particularly if the subsystem originally targeted DOS/360. I think in one > of the CMU binders I may even have a programmer's guide describing a > process to do so). > > Adam, To ensure that I'm decoding your email correctly: when you talk > about UTS under VM, do you mean the Amdahl Unix port, is that correct? > > Note: I don't think TUHS has much of anything from Amdahl either, so > pointers to any Unix resources from there would be helpful. I will then see > if I can get them curated if you tell me where to look. > > As far as I knew, the BTL TSS implementation and the Amdahl work > were separate projects and had little, if anything, in common other than > possibly the compiler toolchain. > > This brings me back to Tom. As I understand it, your C compiler for the > 360 ISA was the root C compiler for most later versions targeting it. Was > your compiler a Ritchie front-end or PCC-based, or did it even start as > dmr's and later become Johnson based when that became the front end that > formally defined the language? > > Clem > > Sent from a handheld expect more typos than usual > > On Fri, Nov 13, 2026 at 11:23 AM Adam Thornton > wrote: > >> The TSS-hosted Unix is described in a 1984 paper by W.A. Felton, G.L. >> Miller, and J.M. Milner: "A *UNIX* System Implementation for System/370". >> >> It appears on p.1751 of the AT&T Bell Laboratories Technical Journal; I >> have it collected in the October 1984 Vol. 63 No. 8 Part 2 issue, which has >> "The UNIX System" on the cover. >> >> I don't know of anyone who has gotten this Unix running under emulation. >> >> UTS is quite easy; there's Moshix's YouTube video explaining it and once >> you get it running, it's just a v7 system with a nice screen editor >> ("ned"). It is still being developed for (sort of): cf. >> https://github.com/athornton/utsnap (I'm also working on a 3270 emulator >> that will soon, but does not yet, do both GOCA vector graphics and PS-based >> raster graphics (https://github.com/athornton/tn3270). The first >> application is to use the technique described in >> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-NAT_K7ng6A to do a proper Space >> Invaders port. Both of these are largely vibecoded, so if that offends >> you, steer clear. >> >> There's a second reason a subsecond sleep driver might be useful, but >> that's a secret for now until I know whether the idea is even feasible. >> >> Adam >> >> On Fri, Nov 13, 2026 at 8:15 AM Clem Cole via TUHS wrote: >> >>> Below >>> >>> >>> Sent from a handheld expect more typos than usual >>> >>> On Fri, Nov 13, 2026 at 2:50 AM wrote: >>> >>> > "Charles H Sauer (he/him) via TUHS" wrote: >>> > >>> > > There was some Unix for the 370 before AIX/370, but I never had >>> hands on >>> > > experience with it or much knowledge of it. >>> > >>> > IIRC, it was called IX/370. I remember that it was based on System III, >>> > and came out shortly after AT&T released System V. I remember articles >>> in >>> > rags like InfoWorld wondering if IBM putting their weight behind System >>> > III would derail AT&T's efforts with System V. So this would be early >>> > to mid-80s, before AIX and the RT/PC. >>> > >>> > Inside the Bell System, Unix ran on the 370, and Amdahl had their own >>> > port(s), but I don't know the timelines or specifics of those. >>> >>> My memory of the Bell Labs Unix for the 370, was hosted in some way under >>> TSS. But I never knew the specifics. Finding that code base for TUHS >>> would be a nice addition. >>> >>> ISTR: when CMU was replacing their TSS based 360, one of the proposed >>> solutions was to do the same; although I have no idea how serious it was. >>> >>> > >>> > >>> > HTH, >>> > >>> > Arnold >>> > >>> >> From tuhs at tuhs.org Sat Nov 14 11:04:30 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Tom Lyon via TUHS) Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 17:04:30 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <94395EC5-43AC-4FAC-93BB-552F2B900888@gmail.com> References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> <94395EC5-43AC-4FAC-93BB-552F2B900888@gmail.com> Message-ID: No need to ask AI 😀: https://akapugs.blog/2018/05/12/370unixpart1/ BTW, only 370s and beyond, not 360s. On Fri, Nov 13, 2026 at 2:19 PM Peter Yardley via TUHS wrote: > Hi, > > At the Uni I worked for we had at one point, in the 80s in think, UTS > (Universal Timesharing System) a UNIX implementation, running on VM on an > Amdahl V8. AI says it was launched in 1981 and developed at Princeton and > ran on IBM 360s/370s. > > > On 13 Nov 2026, at 6:50 pm, Arnold Robbins via TUHS > wrote: > > > > "Charles H Sauer (he/him) via TUHS" wrote: > > > >> There was some Unix for the 370 before AIX/370, but I never had hands > on > >> experience with it or much knowledge of it. > > > > IIRC, it was called IX/370. I remember that it was based on System III, > > and came out shortly after AT&T released System V. I remember articles in > > rags like InfoWorld wondering if IBM putting their weight behind System > > III would derail AT&T's efforts with System V. So this would be early > > to mid-80s, before AIX and the RT/PC. > > > > Inside the Bell System, Unix ran on the 370, and Amdahl had > > their own port(s), but I don't know the timelines or specifics > > of those. > > > > HTH, > > > > Arnold > > > .1.3.6.1.4.1.8852.4.2 > Peter Yardley > peter.martin.yardley at gmail.com > > From tuhs at tuhs.org Sat Nov 14 11:48:31 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Peter Yardley via TUHS) Date: Sat, 14 Nov 2026 12:48:31 +1100 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> <94395EC5-43AC-4FAC-93BB-552F2B900888@gmail.com> Message-ID: Just to clarify I get an AI result front of queue whenever I search now. If I use it in a post I will declare it to be from AI. Accuracy seems to vary a bit. > On 14 Nov 2026, at 12:04 pm, Tom Lyon wrote: > > No need to ask AI 😀: https://akapugs.blog/2018/05/12/370unixpart1/ > BTW, only 370s and beyond, not 360s. > > On Fri, Nov 13, 2026 at 2:19 PM Peter Yardley via TUHS wrote: > Hi, > > At the Uni I worked for we had at one point, in the 80s in think, UTS (Universal Timesharing System) a UNIX implementation, running on VM on an Amdahl V8. AI says it was launched in 1981 and developed at Princeton and ran on IBM 360s/370s. > > > On 13 Nov 2026, at 6:50 pm, Arnold Robbins via TUHS wrote: > > > > "Charles H Sauer (he/him) via TUHS" wrote: > > > >> There was some Unix for the 370 before AIX/370, but I never had hands on > >> experience with it or much knowledge of it. > > > > IIRC, it was called IX/370. I remember that it was based on System III, > > and came out shortly after AT&T released System V. I remember articles in > > rags like InfoWorld wondering if IBM putting their weight behind System > > III would derail AT&T's efforts with System V. So this would be early > > to mid-80s, before AIX and the RT/PC. > > > > Inside the Bell System, Unix ran on the 370, and Amdahl had > > their own port(s), but I don't know the timelines or specifics > > of those. > > > > HTH, > > > > Arnold > > > .1.3.6.1.4.1.8852.4.2 > Peter Yardley > peter.martin.yardley at gmail.com > .1.3.6.1.4.1.8852.4.2 Peter Yardley peter.martin.yardley at gmail.com From tuhs at tuhs.org Sat Nov 14 12:05:22 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (John Levine via TUHS) Date: 13 Nov 2026 21:05:22 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: References: <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <94395EC5-43AC-4FAC-93BB-552F2B900888@gmail.com> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> Message-ID: <20261114020523.01A80128657B6@ary.qy> It appears that Tom Lyon via TUHS said: >No need to ask AI 😀: https://akapugs.blog/2018/05/12/370unixpart1/ Interesting blog post. I played a little with the unix 11/45 in the E-quad courtesy of Peter Eichenberger who was (still is) an old friend from high school. >BTW, only 370s and beyond, not 360s. 360's didn't have any sort of memory relocation or virtual memory other than the 360/67 so there's no way you could run a reasonable Unix on a 360. The 370s had quite decent paging so sure, Unix could run on that, and several did. From tuhs at tuhs.org Sun Nov 15 02:35:54 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Arnold Robbins via TUHS) Date: Sat, 14 Nov 2026 09:35:54 -0700 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> Message-ID: <202611141635.6AEGZsBP035012@freefriends.org> Adam Thornton via TUHS wrote: > The TSS-hosted Unix is described in a 1984 paper by W.A. Felton, G.L. > Miller, and J.M. Milner: "A *UNIX* System Implementation for System/370". > > It appears on p.1751 of the AT&T Bell Laboratories Technical Journal; I > have it collected in the October 1984 Vol. 63 No. 8 Part 2 issue, which has > "The UNIX System" on the cover. > > I don't know of anyone who has gotten this Unix running under emulation. Is the code for this even available? Memory is vague, but I seem to recall that AT&T had IBM do some modifications to TSS in order to support running Unix on top of it, so one would need this modified TSS even to get started, no? Thanks, Arnold From tuhs at tuhs.org Sun Nov 15 02:46:18 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Arnold Robbins via TUHS) Date: Sat, 14 Nov 2026 09:46:18 -0700 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> Message-ID: <202611141646.6AEGkInH035795@freefriends.org> At some point Amdahl had System V running as well. I don't remember any more details, other than that at a USENIX, someone was talking about compiling software, and that using the system was "like cat-ing the makefile". :-) I also remember that Amdahl did a nice trick. On the original Unix filesystem, they noted that most files were small, so they put the first N bytes of a file into the leftover space in the block together with the inode, avoiding an expensive seek. To change the subject, ISTR that Sun had SunOS 4.x running on S/370 hardware, but it never made it out into the wild. Anybody know anything about that? Larry? Thanks, Arnold Adam Thornton via TUHS wrote: > Yes, "UTS under VM" is the Amdahl Unix port. I really like it, in that it > has the simplicity of v7, a nice screen editor, and doesn't have the most > annoying thing about v7 which is the 16-bit address space limitation. > > If only it had a TCP/IP implementation, it'd be just about perfect... > > Adam From tuhs at tuhs.org Sun Nov 15 03:03:34 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Tom Lyon via TUHS) Date: Sat, 14 Nov 2026 09:03:34 -0800 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <202611141646.6AEGkInH035795@freefriends.org> References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> <202611141646.6AEGkInH035795@freefriends.org> Message-ID: I don't think SunOS (<5.0) made it to S/370, but I seem to recall 3 separate ports of Solaris (SunOS >= 5) to IBM compatible mainframes! Once for Amdahl, once for Hitachi, once for Fujitsu(iirc). Paid for by the hardware vendor, so not available to competitors. Perhaps slightly different points of evolution of S/370 architecture. On Sat, Nov 14, 2026 at 8:47 AM Arnold Robbins via TUHS wrote: > At some point Amdahl had System V running as well. I don't remember > any more details, other than that at a USENIX, someone was talking > about compiling software, and that using the system was "like cat-ing > the makefile". :-) > > I also remember that Amdahl did a nice trick. On the original Unix > filesystem, they noted that most files were small, so they put > the first N bytes of a file into the leftover space in the block > together with the inode, avoiding an expensive seek. > > To change the subject, ISTR that Sun had SunOS 4.x running on S/370 > hardware, but it never made it out into the wild. Anybody know > anything about that? Larry? > > Thanks, > > Arnold > > Adam Thornton via TUHS wrote: > > > Yes, "UTS under VM" is the Amdahl Unix port. I really like it, in that > it > > has the simplicity of v7, a nice screen editor, and doesn't have the most > > annoying thing about v7 which is the 16-bit address space limitation. > > > > If only it had a TCP/IP implementation, it'd be just about perfect... > > > > Adam > From tuhs at tuhs.org Sun Nov 15 03:11:12 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Arnold Robbins via TUHS) Date: Sat, 14 Nov 2026 10:11:12 -0700 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> <202611141646.6AEGkInH035795@freefriends.org> Message-ID: <202611141711.6AEHBCGn037508@freefriends.org> I can't argue; ISTR Guy Harris talking about SunOS on the S/370 on USENET in the 4.x timeframe, but it was a lllloooonnnngggg time ago. Thanks, Arnold Tom Lyon wrote: > I don't think SunOS (<5.0) made it to S/370, but I seem to recall 3 > separate ports of Solaris (SunOS >= 5) to IBM compatible mainframes! Once > for Amdahl, once for Hitachi, once for Fujitsu(iirc). Paid for by the > hardware vendor, so not available to competitors. Perhaps slightly > different points of evolution of S/370 architecture. > > On Sat, Nov 14, 2026 at 8:47 AM Arnold Robbins via TUHS > wrote: > > > At some point Amdahl had System V running as well. I don't remember > > any more details, other than that at a USENIX, someone was talking > > about compiling software, and that using the system was "like cat-ing > > the makefile". :-) > > > > I also remember that Amdahl did a nice trick. On the original Unix > > filesystem, they noted that most files were small, so they put > > the first N bytes of a file into the leftover space in the block > > together with the inode, avoiding an expensive seek. > > > > To change the subject, ISTR that Sun had SunOS 4.x running on S/370 > > hardware, but it never made it out into the wild. Anybody know > > anything about that? Larry? > > > > Thanks, > > > > Arnold > > > > Adam Thornton via TUHS wrote: > > > > > Yes, "UTS under VM" is the Amdahl Unix port. I really like it, in that > > it > > > has the simplicity of v7, a nice screen editor, and doesn't have the most > > > annoying thing about v7 which is the 16-bit address space limitation. > > > > > > If only it had a TCP/IP implementation, it'd be just about perfect... > > > > > > Adam > > From tuhs at tuhs.org Sun Nov 15 04:15:16 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Clem Cole via TUHS) Date: Sat, 14 Nov 2026 13:15:16 -0500 Subject: [TUHS] [COFF] Re: Re: AS/400 and TUI worlds: were they (very) isolated from UNIX? In-Reply-To: <202611141635.6AEGZsBP035012@freefriends.org> References: <20261112021405.59F161282D0EF@ary.qy> <1ED75CE0-9E7F-4F22-9335-AFA2E055331E@canb.auug.org.au> <2cdf7350-eded-4689-9b8c-611c445dc6b5@technologists.com> <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> <202611141635.6AEGZsBP035012@freefriends.org> Message-ID: Below Sent from a handheld expect more typos than usual On Sat, Nov 14, 2026 at 11:35 AM wrote: > Adam Thornton via TUHS wrote: > > > The TSS-hosted Unix is described in a 1984 paper by W.A. Felton, G.L. > > Miller, and J.M. Milner: "A *UNIX* System Implementation for System/370". > > > > It appears on p.1751 of the AT&T Bell Laboratories Technical Journal; I > > have it collected in the October 1984 Vol. 63 No. 8 Part 2 issue, which > has > > "The UNIX System" on the cover. > > > > I don't know of anyone who has gotten this Unix running under emulation. > > Is the code for this even available? that is a great question. I'd love to find it. > > > Memory is vague, but I seem to recall that AT&T had IBM do some > modifications to TSS in order to support running Unix on top of it, so one > would need this modified TSS even to get started, no? maybe. I haven't looked. I found a website that had what I think was the last IBM TSS release. I know IBM took and put much the CMU work back into their mainline. For instance, I'm fairly sure that work I did with Don Gregg (who did the heavy lifting) to support York APL/360 on TSS went back to both IBM and York (as well as number MTS sites). IBM also hired a few of the CMU people into the TSS group, Dean Hiller being the most prominent (he was TSS's equivalent of Ken, and responsible for many, most maybe, additions/corrections at CMU). Given the fairly small customer base for TSS, if IBM made changes to TSS, I suspect that they would be put into their mainline - thus all of the TSS sites got them. I'd be curious what UNIX would have needed, except for one core thing and another (device support), TSS, had a large number of systems calls that could provide a fairly Unixy process environment. The FS was hierarchical (ISTR TSS used periods not slash as the separator). The two places I can think of quickly that they differ, is that a TSS task (as IBM called a process) was always attached to the debugger/command interpreter; and the way devices were handled, as I don't remember there being any namespace similar to /dev. Thinking a little more, open/close/read/ write should've been fair direct in mapping, but things like ioctl, not as easily. In my own case, since TSS was the first large system that got fairly engaged with, I was bummed when I encountered the DEC OS on the different systems that didn't have the debugger loaded. I can imagine a number of ways to create unixy features so pipes and interprocess communicate would have been straightforward. They had a solid shared memory scheme, and ISTR they split some subsystems, such as ISAM (called VISAM on TSS) into smaller processes Unix style. I would guess that fork/exec/wait might have need be overhauled a bit, but I can imagine that to support them fully, TSS might have needed some tweaks. > So besides it being 32-bit *vs*. 16, since TSS was a virtual memory system, it would have been a nice system with of the PDP-11 issue removed. It also brings up a interesting question if a TSS task could communicate with a UNIX process and vice-versa. Another couple of questions I would have is could the native tool chain of both the TSS side and hosted UNIX side, be used to create executable for the other, and could both sides load and start programs in ether side. Clem > From tuhs at tuhs.org Sun Nov 15 12:10:08 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Jonathan Gray via TUHS) Date: Sun, 15 Nov 2026 13:10:08 +1100 Subject: [TUHS] SunOS 4 S/370 port In-Reply-To: <202611141711.6AEHBCGn037508@freefriends.org> References: <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> <202611141646.6AEGkInH035795@freefriends.org> <202611141711.6AEHBCGn037508@freefriends.org> Message-ID: "Another implementation has been done for IBM 370/XA compatible main frames." Joseph P. Moran, SunOS Virtual Memory Implementation Proceedings of the Spring 1988 EUUG Conference, p 294 https://datamuseum.dk/wiki/Bits:Keyword/DKUUG/EUUG republished in AUUGN Vol 9, No 3, June 1988, p 52 https://www.tuhs.org/Archive/Documentation/AUUGN/AUUGN-V09.3.pdf https://archive.org/details/AUUGN_V09_3/page/n53/mode/2up > Looking through the Customer Distributed Bugs List June 1989, I see the > following (on page 290) > > Reference Number: 1015126 > Release: 4.0 > Synopsis: uninitialized local variable referenced in cron > > Description: > In the port of SunOS 4.0 to the IBM 370 architecture, cron gets > a memory fault and dumps core, usually after executing its first > event [ .. ] > Is there really a port to the 370 ?? Has anyone heard anything about this ? Jason Heirtzler in comp.sys.sun, Jul 27, 1989 SunOs 4.0 on IBM 370 ?? https://tuhs.org/Usenet/comp.sys.sun/1989-July/002998.html https://groups.google.com/g/comp.sys.sun/c/vKJe_d6bBoE/m/krFwM5M2uoQJ On Sat, Nov 14, 2026 at 10:11:12AM -0700, Arnold Robbins via TUHS wrote: > I can't argue; ISTR Guy Harris talking about SunOS on the S/370 > on USENET in the 4.x timeframe, but it was a lllloooonnnngggg time ago. > > Thanks, > > Arnold > > Tom Lyon wrote: > > > I don't think SunOS (<5.0) made it to S/370, but I seem to recall 3 > > separate ports of Solaris (SunOS >= 5) to IBM compatible mainframes! Once > > for Amdahl, once for Hitachi, once for Fujitsu(iirc). Paid for by the > > hardware vendor, so not available to competitors. Perhaps slightly > > different points of evolution of S/370 architecture. > > > > On Sat, Nov 14, 2026 at 8:47 AM Arnold Robbins via TUHS > > wrote: > > > > > At some point Amdahl had System V running as well. I don't remember > > > any more details, other than that at a USENIX, someone was talking > > > about compiling software, and that using the system was "like cat-ing > > > the makefile". :-) > > > > > > I also remember that Amdahl did a nice trick. On the original Unix > > > filesystem, they noted that most files were small, so they put > > > the first N bytes of a file into the leftover space in the block > > > together with the inode, avoiding an expensive seek. > > > > > > To change the subject, ISTR that Sun had SunOS 4.x running on S/370 > > > hardware, but it never made it out into the wild. Anybody know > > > anything about that? Larry? > > > > > > Thanks, > > > > > > Arnold > > > > > > Adam Thornton via TUHS wrote: > > > > > > > Yes, "UTS under VM" is the Amdahl Unix port. I really like it, in that > > > it > > > > has the simplicity of v7, a nice screen editor, and doesn't have the most > > > > annoying thing about v7 which is the 16-bit address space limitation. > > > > > > > > If only it had a TCP/IP implementation, it'd be just about perfect... > > > > > > > > Adam > > > From tuhs at tuhs.org Sun Nov 15 16:46:43 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Arnold Robbins via TUHS) Date: Sat, 14 Nov 2026 23:46:43 -0700 Subject: [TUHS] SunOS 4 S/370 port In-Reply-To: References: <8f3ee23a-18f6-4ab3-ba59-142e69f963a8@technologists.com> <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> <202611141646.6AEGkInH035795@freefriends.org> <202611141711.6AEHBCGn037508@freefriends.org> Message-ID: <202611150646.6AF6khuq093145@freefriends.org> Thanks for this. I can remember stuff from USENET from 40 years ago but have trouble remembering the names of neighbors... :-( Arnold Jonathan Gray wrote: > "Another implementation has been done for IBM 370/XA compatible main frames." > > Joseph P. Moran, SunOS Virtual Memory Implementation > Proceedings of the Spring 1988 EUUG Conference, p 294 > https://datamuseum.dk/wiki/Bits:Keyword/DKUUG/EUUG > > republished in AUUGN Vol 9, No 3, June 1988, p 52 > https://www.tuhs.org/Archive/Documentation/AUUGN/AUUGN-V09.3.pdf > https://archive.org/details/AUUGN_V09_3/page/n53/mode/2up > > > Looking through the Customer Distributed Bugs List June 1989, I see the > > following (on page 290) > > > > Reference Number: 1015126 > > Release: 4.0 > > Synopsis: uninitialized local variable referenced in cron > > > > Description: > > In the port of SunOS 4.0 to the IBM 370 architecture, cron gets > > a memory fault and dumps core, usually after executing its first > > event [ .. ] > > Is there really a port to the 370 ?? Has anyone heard anything about this ? > > Jason Heirtzler in comp.sys.sun, Jul 27, 1989 > SunOs 4.0 on IBM 370 ?? > https://tuhs.org/Usenet/comp.sys.sun/1989-July/002998.html > https://groups.google.com/g/comp.sys.sun/c/vKJe_d6bBoE/m/krFwM5M2uoQJ > > On Sat, Nov 14, 2026 at 10:11:12AM -0700, Arnold Robbins via TUHS wrote: > > I can't argue; ISTR Guy Harris talking about SunOS on the S/370 > > on USENET in the 4.x timeframe, but it was a lllloooonnnngggg time ago. > > > > Thanks, > > > > Arnold > > > > Tom Lyon wrote: > > > > > I don't think SunOS (<5.0) made it to S/370, but I seem to recall 3 > > > separate ports of Solaris (SunOS >= 5) to IBM compatible mainframes! Once > > > for Amdahl, once for Hitachi, once for Fujitsu(iirc). Paid for by the > > > hardware vendor, so not available to competitors. Perhaps slightly > > > different points of evolution of S/370 architecture. > > > > > > On Sat, Nov 14, 2026 at 8:47 AM Arnold Robbins via TUHS > > > wrote: > > > > > > > At some point Amdahl had System V running as well. I don't remember > > > > any more details, other than that at a USENIX, someone was talking > > > > about compiling software, and that using the system was "like cat-ing > > > > the makefile". :-) > > > > > > > > I also remember that Amdahl did a nice trick. On the original Unix > > > > filesystem, they noted that most files were small, so they put > > > > the first N bytes of a file into the leftover space in the block > > > > together with the inode, avoiding an expensive seek. > > > > > > > > To change the subject, ISTR that Sun had SunOS 4.x running on S/370 > > > > hardware, but it never made it out into the wild. Anybody know > > > > anything about that? Larry? > > > > > > > > Thanks, > > > > > > > > Arnold > > > > > > > > Adam Thornton via TUHS wrote: > > > > > > > > > Yes, "UTS under VM" is the Amdahl Unix port. I really like it, in that > > > > it > > > > > has the simplicity of v7, a nice screen editor, and doesn't have the most > > > > > annoying thing about v7 which is the 16-bit address space limitation. > > > > > > > > > > If only it had a TCP/IP implementation, it'd be just about perfect... > > > > > > > > > > Adam > > > > From tuhs at tuhs.org Sun Nov 15 21:30:33 2026 From: tuhs at tuhs.org (Jonathan Gray via TUHS) Date: Sun, 15 Nov 2026 22:30:33 +1100 Subject: [TUHS] SunOS 4 S/370 port In-Reply-To: <202611150646.6AF6khuq093145@freefriends.org> References: <202611130750.6AD7oo6V069963@freefriends.org> <202611141646.6AEGkInH035795@freefriends.org> <202611141711.6AEHBCGn037508@freefriends.org> <202611150646.6AF6khuq093145@freefriends.org> Message-ID: "NAS joins Sun to co-develop Unix system" Rosemary Hamilton in Computerworld 3 Aug 1987, p 16 https://archive.org/details/computerworld2131unse/page/16/mode/1up "We have ported SunOS to the 370 architecture as part of a joint development project with National Advanced Systems." Jim Voll in comp.unix.wizards, Aug 24, 1988 SunOS on non-Sun hardware https://tuhs.org/Usenet/comp.unix.wizards/1988-August/030363.html https://groups.google.com/g/comp.unix.wizards/c/zdoNI3Fwckk/m/OO9bVAQdeYgJ National Advanced Systems became Hitachi Data Systems in 1989. On Sat, Nov 14, 2026 at 11:46:43PM -0700, Arnold Robbins via TUHS wrote: > Thanks for this. > > I can remember stuff from USENET from 40 years ago but have > trouble remembering the names of neighbors... :-( > > Arnold > > Jonathan Gray wrote: > > > "Another implementation has been done for IBM 370/XA compatible main frames." > > > > Joseph P. Moran, SunOS Virtual Memory Implementation > > Proceedings of the Spring 1988 EUUG Conference, p 294 > > https://datamuseum.dk/wiki/Bits:Keyword/DKUUG/EUUG > > > > republished in AUUGN Vol 9, No 3, June 1988, p 52 > > https://www.tuhs.org/Archive/Documentation/AUUGN/AUUGN-V09.3.pdf > > https://archive.org/details/AUUGN_V09_3/page/n53/mode/2up > > > > > Looking through the Customer Distributed Bugs List June 1989, I see the > > > following (on page 290) > > > > > > Reference Number: 1015126 > > > Release: 4.0 > > > Synopsis: uninitialized local variable referenced in cron > > > > > > Description: > > > In the port of SunOS 4.0 to the IBM 370 architecture, cron gets > > > a memory fault and dumps core, usually after executing its first > > > event [ .. ] > > > Is there really a port to the 370 ?? Has anyone heard anything about this ? > > > > Jason Heirtzler in comp.sys.sun, Jul 27, 1989 > > SunOs 4.0 on IBM 370 ?? > > https://tuhs.org/Usenet/comp.sys.sun/1989-July/002998.html > > https://groups.google.com/g/comp.sys.sun/c/vKJe_d6bBoE/m/krFwM5M2uoQJ > > > > On Sat, Nov 14, 2026 at 10:11:12AM -0700, Arnold Robbins via TUHS wrote: > > > I can't argue; ISTR Guy Harris talking about SunOS on the S/370 > > > on USENET in the 4.x timeframe, but it was a lllloooonnnngggg time ago. > > > > > > Thanks, > > > > > > Arnold > > > > > > Tom Lyon wrote: > > > > > > > I don't think SunOS (<5.0) made it to S/370, but I seem to recall 3 > > > > separate ports of Solaris (SunOS >= 5) to IBM compatible mainframes! Once > > > > for Amdahl, once for Hitachi, once for Fujitsu(iirc). Paid for by the > > > > hardware vendor, so not available to competitors. Perhaps slightly > > > > different points of evolution of S/370 architecture. > > > > > > > > On Sat, Nov 14, 2026 at 8:47 AM Arnold Robbins via TUHS > > > > wrote: > > > > > > > > > At some point Amdahl had System V running as well. I don't remember > > > > > any more details, other than that at a USENIX, someone was talking > > > > > about compiling software, and that using the system was "like cat-ing > > > > > the makefile". :-) > > > > > > > > > > I also remember that Amdahl did a nice trick. On the original Unix > > > > > filesystem, they noted that most files were small, so they put > > > > > the first N bytes of a file into the leftover space in the block > > > > > together with the inode, avoiding an expensive seek. > > > > > > > > > > To change the subject, ISTR that Sun had SunOS 4.x running on S/370 > > > > > hardware, but it never made it out into the wild. Anybody know > > > > > anything about that? Larry? > > > > > > > > > > Thanks, > > > > > > > > > > Arnold > > > > > > > > > > Adam Thornton via TUHS wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > Yes, "UTS under VM" is the Amdahl Unix port. I really like it, in that > > > > > it > > > > > > has the simplicity of v7, a nice screen editor, and doesn't have the most > > > > > > annoying thing about v7 which is the 16-bit address space limitation. > > > > > > > > > > > > If only it had a TCP/IP implementation, it'd be just about perfect... > > > > > > > > > > > > Adam > > > > >